Originally Posted by Carbine
I think Tom Brady will go down as the consensus GOAT. Because the major majority of fans value rings so much.
I do find it incredibly funny that something Brady literally had no control over effected his legacy in so many people's minds. The guy nobody even knew of picks it off and Brady gets GOAT talk. Marshawn pounds it in and the Pats lose and nobody would be talking about Brady the GOAT. Each scenario Brady had as much impact as me and GOBB.
And what if Tyree doesn't catch the ball with his head and what if Manningham doesn't make that absurd catch in 2012?, etc.. Brady would have 5 rings(lets say with a lost tonight) going by your logic and it would further cement his status of GOAT.