Also taking Lo Duca over Posada is as biased as one can be in this thread. Even most Met fans should realize this isn't even close to being true.
Neither have been too good or bad in the field this year (although Posada has the edge here too) but Posada is MILES ahead of Lo Duca when it comes to offense. Lo Duca has the edge AVG and yet Posada still has a much better OBP (which means more) and hits for way more power than Lo Duca.
been hitting like .400 since the all-star break
That's nice... what about all the games before the all-star break (which was more than half the season)???