Originally Posted by craigthomasb
comeback player of the year should go to Alex Smith IMO, if he finnishes the season strong
I think Favre will likely get it but I think Cedric Benson deserves it the most. He really resurrected his career this season.
And I would give it to Vince Young before I gave it to Alex Smith. Vince Young definitely deserves it after the way his career was seemingly over and then comes back and saves the Titans season.