Kobe has been torched left and right his entire career, this has already been debated on ISH for years. He's had some good defensive efforts (and some abismal ones), but those are exceptions. He's an average defender, nothing more.
Keep telling yourself that buddy.
Those damn writers who voted him to 6 all-defensive teams must not being seeing the same thing you're seeing. Being average doesn't garner you that type of recognition. I'm sorry, I just don't agree with your assessment.