Originally Posted by ClutchOver9000
There are only 4 QBs that are undisputedly better than Eli and thats Brady, Peyton, Rodgers, and Brees.
Everyone else is debatable. Everyone else.
Now if you are at best, the 5th ranked QB at your position (which is top tier), and at worst top 10, then you're a damn good QB.
the top tier (ELITE) is Brees/Rodgers/Brady...that's it
Peyton has to prove himself to be the same IMO
either way, Eli is not "elite"...the "elite" is the best in the league, or arguably the best...which Eli isn't