Originally Posted by -p.tiddy-
Many people have Eli ranked as an elite...#1 overall even
heis good but he is also a career 82.0 passer rating QB not on the same level as others...
he also gets 95% of the credit for the Giants' rings which is just too much cred
What does Eli' career rating and what he did his first 4 years have to do with the type of player he is NOW?
People rate him on what he has done now and in the previous year or so. Him struggling early in his career means nothing in terms of ranking him now as compared to his counterparts.