Originally Posted by Myth
Hey, I'm just trying to see it from the buyer's perspective too. I'd be bummed if I spent $250 on something that turned out to be faulty, even if it is still an overall good deal.
This. However, if OP did inform on broken hard drive it's a fair & done deal. If he didn't then the buyer has every right to complain.
It's like saying what if you buy a refurbished phone from Apple and realize that the screen is completely shattered..