Originally Posted by Qwyjibo
The only somewhat questionable ones were Berkman and Giles (who was probably the most underrated player of the past 20 years). And both were still great hitters. Everyone else is absolutely comparable and several of them better than Cabrera.
(based purely on offense)
And those were the names I was referring to. I'm not knocking them as hitters, I can just say with some confidence they, at their peak, weren't as good as Cabrera has been the last two seasons.
And the Dodgers comeback from 6 down and win on a wild throw into the OF in the bottom of the 9th.