If melo wins MVP and finals MVP this season does he pass wade all-time?

[PJR]

Op is a phaggit.

[Legends66NBA7]

Even if Melo wins MVP (as of now, don't think it will happen... I got Durant winning it), Wade's been consistently the better player when healthy and much more potent in the playoffs, so I just can't see it happening with the MVP+Finals MVP+Championship, even with a dominant run. It's just the case of being more consistent than a 1 year dominance, which Wade has probably had like 4-5 years better than the 12-13 Melo so far.

It does push Melo in the Top 50, quite easily.

Melo has been an evolutionary version of Glenn Robinson. Nothing more, nothing less.

I've actually seen that comparison before too with Melo and Robinson before, but yeah Melo's offensive skillset just puts him at an elite level over Robinson as players.

[LockoutOver11]

wade took down the mighty pistons.... and a pretty good dallas team.

wade was like a crazy 6'3 point guard skilled baller that could score with the best sg's and block your shiiiiiitttt...

so far i agreed that durant has surpassed anything melo's accomplished, and wade is not gonna be touched by melo this season...


but then theres always the factor of New York.

He gets New York a championship... then... you know how that is. Knicks have been starving for this, and so has the league.

To be in even top 25 for me, he's gotta go to at least 3 more conference finals. Beat Heat, beat a legit contender DRose Chicago team, and Beat the Thunder or even the Spurs.

But how many years can the Knicks stay at a contender level Let's say they win a chip. Tyson will get hurt sooner or later. Smith will not be resigned. Kidd will retire.

Felton Iman Melo ____ and ____ ? Those blanks gotta end up being ****ing Al Horford and some other emerging Center.

[Sarcastic]

Prime Shaq? Are you 10?

Shaq was still a 20/10 player in Miami, and capable of much more, but he took a back seat to Wade for the good of the team. He was 33 years old. He was not at his peak, but he was certainly still in his prime.

[Halipender]

Wade has all star mvp, scoring titles besides 2 rings. Melo is levels behind

[hon]

He's got a mean mugshot...

[Purch]

08-09 Wade>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Any Melo season.

This. Melo fans have a weird sense of history

[Chrono90]

[FONT="Arial Black"][COLOR="Black"]IF[/COLOR][/FONT]

Just trying to show people its a big "if."

[Dresta]

Shaq was still a 20/10 player in Miami, and capable of much more, but he took a back seat to Wade for the good of the team. He was 33 years old. He was not at his peak, but he was certainly still in his prime.

If you don't think Shaq was on a steep downslope at that time then you are ****ing brainless.

[Human Error]

Hmm this is an interesting thread. Let's see if Carmelo wins the Finals MVP!

[Coolaak]

Wade played with Lebron & Prime Shaq
You give Melo those 2, he would win 2 more rings then what wade has now

[PJR]

Wade played with Lebron & Prime Shaq
You give Melo those 2, he would win 2 more rings then what wade has now

No he wouldn't. Speculative conjecture.