Adrian Peterson vs. Reggie Bush

[dab0yech0]

McFadden will top them both very soon!!!!!!

Take him away from the Raiders and they will win 2 games at the most if their lucky.

[crisoner]

Take him away from the Raiders and they will win 2 games at the most if their lucky.

We got a young squad son with lots of talent.

Only thing holding us back is time and AL DAVIS.
Man.....the AL DAVIS part it the one that scares me.

[dab0yech0]

We got a young squad son with lots of talent.

Only thing holding us back is time and AL DAVIS.
Man.....the AL DAVIS part it the one that scares me.

Its ok I feel you, Sterling has been horrible to us too until the last couple of years. Al Davis though goes on power swings however and loses his mind every once in awhile. I like McFadden and hopefully Davis doesn't treat him like he did Marcus Allen.

[crisoner]

Its ok I feel you, Sterling has been horrible to us too until the last couple of years. Al Davis though goes on power swings however and loses his mind every once in awhile. I like McFadden and hopefully Davis doesn't treat him like he did Marcus Allen.

Glad you mention that!!!! I agree 100%.

Jonathan Stewart is another phenomenal talent, he just faced a brutal front 7 from Minnesota yesterday and really couldn't get a single hole to run through.

AP is a beast no doubt but he has Hutchinson blocking for him, it's rediculous what one all-world OL can do to a RB's career. I mean yesterday, Minnesota practically beat a good team with 9 players. Their front 7, Hutchinson and AP/Taylor.

Stewart is just as good as Barber or AP at breaking tackles, he has the vision and he has the cutting ability. But his OL is no where near as good as Dallas's or Minnesota's. Stewart still returned a 90 kick off return yesterday but it got taking back on a very questionable blocking call, where the Panther player barely touched the dude.

McFadden and Stewart are my two favorite RB's in the league already, and of course I got love for Barber, LT, and AP.

[Rameek]

Reggie Bush can't run the ball.

I agree!

I would rather build around the Raiders Bush than the NO Bush!
I dont think AP will ever play 16 games... He likes running into people to much. I hope he learns as he gets older or he wont make it to 28 in this league.


I think Barber is the most complete back... Next to a prime healthy LT.

To answer the question I would rather AP though. Bush could be my 3rd down back and return specialist.

Bush is to easy to tackle when he runs between the tackles. He needs space to make someone miss. Cant run through creases in the O-line.

Did I mention he's too easy to bring down when runs in close quarters...???

[stewen12]

joke?

[lefthook00]

McFadden will top them both very soon!!!!!!

I think Felix Jones looks better than McFadden right now...but its probably cuz hes on the best team in the NFL. He is more compact and almost as fast...every time I see McFadden play he just stops and falls over every time he's touched...I wanna say he's easier to tackle than Bush.

My favorite is definitely AP, so jerky and violent. Second is Marion Barber cuz he's on my team and he's straight up DIESEL.

[Skywalker]

Felix Jones is a monster wtf Dallas keep piling on the monsters.

[-primetime-]

Reggie Bush can't run the ball.

yep...

IMO Bush should officially be labeled a WR now

he lines up as a WR more than he does a RB



btw...IF Bush was really that great of a RB then they would stop using him at punt return...

and I don't give a damn how great the Vikes o-line is...that team can't pass the ball for sh*t and that would make it hard as hell for any RB.

[High Potential]

yep...

IMO Bush should officially be labeled a WR now

he lines up as a WR more than he does a RB



btw...IF Bush was really that great of a RB then they would stop using him at punt return...

and I don't give a damn how great the Vikes o-line is...that team can't pass the ball for sh*t and that would make it hard as hell for any RB.

That doesn't make any sense. If he's the most dangerous punt returner on the team, why not use him there? Maurice Jones-Drew returns punts and kickoffs, does that mean he isn't a great RB?

[Smokee]

Reggie Bush and Mcfadden are both overrated. Both are good, but next to Adrian Peterson they are overrated. AP is like the next great running back. You'd have to be blind or not watch football to see the difference between him and just about everyone else that plays right now. He runs like a horse with ridiculous burst. And he does it while they stack the line with 8 man fronts.

Mcfadden is like Michael Bush almost. Both big long backs. Except it seems like Mcfadden is more of a poohsee.

Reggie Bush is good, but he gets probably the most opportunities out of any player in the league. Even then he didn't do much last year even tho like 3/4's of that offense was based around getting him the ball.

[-primetime-]

[COLOR="Red"]That doesn't make any sense[/COLOR]. If he's the most dangerous punt returner on the team, why not use him there? Maurice Jones-Drew returns punts and kickoffs, does that mean he isn't a great RB?

happens all the time...

in fact Peterson himself was used as a return man at the begining of his rookie year...once they figured out how great he is they stopped useing him there.

I am sure that the Charger's "most dangerous" return man is LT...

any Dallas fan would tell you that for the past 5 years Terence Newman is our best return man...yet we RARELY used him at PR at all because we didn't want him to get hurt. Newman broke Kansas State records as a punt returner....he is a bad ass to say the least. Adam Jones may be better now but we can afford to lose him.

[High Potential]

happens all the time...

in fact Peterson himself was used as a return man at the begining of his rookie year...once they figured out how great he is they stopped useing him there.

any Dallas fan would tell you that for the past 5 years Terence Newman is our best return man...yet we RARELY used him at PR at all because we didn't want him to get hurt. Newman broke Kansas State records as a punt returner....he is a bad ass to say the least. Adam Jones may be better now but we can afford to lose him.

But what about Jones-Drew?

And the reason they don't use Peterson returning punts is because he goes all out every play and is injury prone enough just running the ball. He still returns kicks and punts sometimes, when they need him too.

Just because the Cowboys don't use their best return man doesn't mean every other team doesn't.

Again

[wTFaMonkey]

You do know being fast doesn't automatically give you the ability to run routes and catch balls right? With that logic Drew Carter, Derek Hagan, and Donnie Avery are better than Ernest Wilford, Amani Toomer and Derrick Mason? Why don't track stars just all become NFL receivers then?

i dont know what you are talking about...

donnie avery plays for the st luis rams..

he was a star reciver for my alma mater..


why dont you read the whole thread before saying anything