ISH's #11 Player of Alltime

[rmt]

Moses Malone - reminded me of an unstoppable train

[Asukal]

Why the fvck is Lebron in this discussion? He is not even halfway his career yet.

I vote for Moses Malone.

[dynasty1978]

Why the fvck is Lebron in this discussion? He is not even halfway his career yet.

I vote for Moses Malone.

They're Bron apologists (minus ShaqAttack). What do you expect?

[ShaqAttack3234]

Why the fvck is Lebron in this discussion? He is not even halfway his career yet.

He's played 8 seasons. How many players were better than Lebron at his peak, or even now?

How many have better resumes than 2 MVPs, 2 finals appearances, 3 conference finals appearances, 5 all-nba first teams, 2 more all-nba second teams, two 60 win seasons, five 50+ win seasons.

He's definitely more than halfway done with the relevant portion of his career, and really, if players weren't as good as prime/peak Lebron and didn't really accomplish more even in a longer career(Oscar, Karl Malone ect.) then why should they be ranked above Lebron?

[dynasty1978]

They're Bron apologists (minus ShaqAttack). What do you expect?

11. West
12. Oscar
13. Moses

[dynasty1978]

He's played 8 seasons. How many players were better than Lebron at his peak, or even now?

How many have better resumes than 2 MVPs, 2 finals appearances, 3 conference finals appearances, 5 all-nba first teams, 2 more all-nba second teams, two 60 win seasons, five 50+ win seasons.

He's definitely more than halfway done with the relevant portion of his career, and really, if players weren't as good as prime/peak Lebron and didn't really accomplish more even in a longer career(Oscar, Karl Malone ect.) then why should they be ranked above Lebron?

With all due respect, with that reasoning, you would have to take a hard look at some of the other greats (e.g., West) and their Finals, Conference Finals appearances, etc., to put this comparison in context.

Let me check that and follow up.

[Deuce Bigalow]

With all due respect, with that reasoning, you would have to take a hard look at some of the other greats (e.g., West) and their Finals, Conference Finals appearances, etc., to put this comparison in context.

Let me check that and follow up.

Jerry West been to 9 Finals
Dr J been to 4 Finals
John Havlicek won 8 championships

[Asukal]

He's played 8 seasons. How many players were better than Lebron at his peak, or even now?

How many have better resumes than 2 MVPs, 2 finals appearances, 3 conference finals appearances, 5 all-nba first teams, 2 more all-nba second teams, two 60 win seasons, five 50+ win seasons.

He's definitely more than halfway done with the relevant portion of his career, and really, if players weren't as good as prime/peak Lebron and didn't really accomplish more even in a longer career(Oscar, Karl Malone ect.) then why should they be ranked above Lebron?

Let's not rank players who aren't even past their primes yet. Lebron will get to this list but not yet, who knows he might end up in top 5 or even number 1. Kobe is in the list because it is safe to say we have seen his best days, he might still get higher though. Lebron is like what? 26? Dude can still accomplish a lot more, lets wait till he gets there.

[EnoughSaid]

I'll take Oscar Robertson.

[jacobgoindum]

Jerry West

NBA Champion (1972)
9 NBA Finals appearances
38 ppg Finals series (1969)
40.6 ppg playoff run
42/13/12 in Game 7 of the 1969 Finals
Finals MVP (1969)
3rd alltime Playoff PPG - 29.1
#1 in Playoff Points and #1 in Laker points after he retired in 1974

[KGMN]

Oscar Robertson

[RRR3]

Oscar Robertson. Holy shit, he's underrated on ISH.

[JMT]

He's played 8 seasons. How many players were better than Lebron at his peak, or even now?

How many have better resumes than 2 MVPs, 2 finals appearances, 3 conference finals appearances, 5 all-nba first teams, 2 more all-nba second teams, two 60 win seasons, five 50+ win seasons.

He's definitely more than halfway done with the relevant portion of his career, and really, if players weren't as good as prime/peak Lebron and didn't really accomplish more even in a longer career(Oscar, Karl Malone ect.) then why should they be ranked above Lebron?

Holy smokes. I honestly thought the votes for LeBron were sarcastic jokes.

Oscar Robertson

[SpecialQue]

Jerry West

NBA Champion (1972)
9 NBA Finals appearances
38 ppg Finals series (1969)
40.6 ppg playoff run
42/13/12 in Game 7 of the 1969 Finals
Finals MVP (1969)
3rd alltime Playoff PPG - 29.1
#1 in Playoff Points and #1 in Laker points after he retired in 1974

I'm taking back my vote for Hondo and placing it for West now. West at #11, Hondo at #12.

[RRR3]

I'm taking back my vote for Hondo and placing it for West now. West at #11, Hondo at #12.

Hondo over Big O.