#4 NBA Player Of All-Time According to InsideHoops

[Asukal]

[StateOfMind12]

Vote tally

Magic - 28
Wilt - 24
Bird - 3
Shaq - 1

[Yung D-Will]

Wilt

Damn apparently I'm not normal enough for Millwad

[fsvr54]

This board is crazy. All they care about is rings. Bird was better than Magic.

[ThunderStruk022]

Magic Johnson

[jongib369]

jlauber should groom you to take his place one day.

Oneday, I will be ready

[Yung D-Will]

The fact I consider Bird's peak so much more dominant than Magic's peak, makes it impossible for me to vote Magic so high.

[Harison]

Wilt Chamberlain once got into a knife fight. The knife lost.

[KBryant24]

magic

[RRR3]

I'd like to know who Magic, who people admit was only an all-time great on one side of the ball, is better than a dominant big man who was arguably the best offensive player AND best defensive player at times during his career? Or are we just basing this off of "HURRRR DURR MAGIC GOTZ FIVE RANGZZZZZ DOEEEEE!"

[eurobum]

[pauk]

Damn Wilt is getting robbed

[Hands of Iron]

This board is crazy. All they care about is rings. Bird was better than Magic.

The fact I consider Bird's peak so much more dominant than Magic's peak, makes it impossible for me to vote Magic so high.

Let's put it this way: The gap between Bird's ability in terms of passing/playmaking/court vision compared to Magic's isn't nearly as large as Magic's scoring/shooting in comparison to Bird, who was also a better rebounder and elite in all the aforementioned categories. Arguably even a better defender as well. Peak Larry Bird - Over 5 Years - was a 27/10/7 on 50/40/90 player.

[Zedja]

Wilt the Stilt

[Poochymama]

Wilt