Anthony Davis vs Kevin Garnett vs Dirk Nowitzki

[PP34Deuce]

THIS IS TOUGH!

AD is the most talented overall. I still say Dirk is the best.

AD with 5-6 more years of high level play will go down as a better All time player than them both.

[HBK_Kliq_2]

I will take Dirk as a franchise player, his 2011 run is something that the other two guys are not capable of.

As a sidekick I will take Kevin Garnett because he's like a tall Scottie Pippen.

Anthony Davis is the odd man out here.

[ThatCoolKid]

I will take Dirk as a franchise player, his 2011 run is something that the other two guys are not capable of.

As a sidekick I will take Kevin Garnett because he's like a tall Scottie Pippen.

Anthony Davis is the odd man out here.

Wow, you are truly an idiot.

[HBK_Kliq_2]

Wow, you are truly an idiot.

Go look at Garnett in playoffs, he scores like Pippen.

[HBK_Kliq_2]

Anthony Davis shouldn't be in this discussion by the way. He's the biggest coward in NBA history. #1 pick that had to hop on the team with the player in #1 career playoff VORP/win shares hahahha that's worse then what Durant did.

[ArbitraryWater]

Wow, you are truly an idiot.

No, he's actually right on that one

[nayte]

I will take kg. This website is getting silly now.

[MadDog]

They're all on equal footing so it depends on who you surround them with. Dirk probably had the best playoff run though.

[tanibanana]

I am not hating on KG. But why do people ranking him over Dirk.

Put Dirk in KG's career, he would have won 2-3 rings.
Put KG in Dirk's career, he would not win any.
But that is just an opinion. So let's go factual.

Their H2H match-up and Playoff match pretty sums it perfectly.

[Shooter]

[Shooter]

I am not hating on KG. But why do people ranking him over Dirk.

Put Dirk in KG's career, he would have won 2-3 rings.
Put KG in Dirk's career, he would not win any.
But that is just an opinion. So let's go factual.

Their H2H match-up and Playoff match pretty sums it perfectly.

I think KG's advantage on defense is bigger than Dirk's on offense.

Both have similarish careers though either way.

1 ring, 1 MVP guys with great longevity and tons of playoffs

[houston]

Dirk better for team impact than those two even though AD more talented.

[Nike D'Antoni]

Dirk Nowitzki Schools Kevin Garnett's Defense - 2002 Playoffs 1st Rd

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YF_e...obodyTouchesMJ

Dirk Nowitzki game-winner vs Celtics (2012.01.11)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CKiO..._channel=Benka

[jalbert009]

I am not hating on KG. But why do people ranking him over Dirk.

Put Dirk in KG's career, he would have won 2-3 rings.
Put KG in Dirk's career, he would not win any.
But that is just an opinion. So let's go factual.

Their H2H match-up and Playoff match pretty sums it perfectly.

KG Had one season in his Twolves days where he had some sort of talent on his team and he took that team to the WCF. Dirk was surounded by talent most of his career. I don't think the mavs were ever considered favourites to win a ring but they were always expected to make the playoffs and at least make the second round.

KGs stint in Boston 2008-11 was only time he had a championship calibre team and he was at the tail end of his prime then and not mention a career changing Injury in 2009. And again, KG didnt waste any time and took that team to the finals and won. I think he was robbed of the FMVP there but hey it is what it is.

[ArbitraryWater]

KG Had one season in his Twolves days where he had some sort of talent on his team and he took that team to the WCF. Dirk was surounded by talent most of his career. I don't think the mavs were ever considered favourites to win a ring but they were always expected to make the playoffs and at least make the second round.

KGs stint in Boston 2008-11 was only time he had a championship calibre team and he was at the tail end of his prime then and not mention a career changing Injury in 2009. And again, KG didnt waste any time and took that team to the finals and won. I think he was robbed of the FMVP there but hey it is what it is.

Quit playing.

Lotta wrongs in here