12 years of Paul Pierce or Carmelo Anthony?

[light]

Assuming equal/ comparable teammates and coaching for both players... Which would you prefer?

I'll take Melo.

Paul Pierce was a coattail riding whiney baby.

[kawhileonard2]

Pierce. He outplayed Kobe and Lebron in the same playoffs twice.

[MadDog]

Pierce although I think in the right situation, Carmelo could have upped his postseason cache. During his final 2 years in Denver, he averaged 29/6/4 on 46% shooting in the playoffs and 31/9/3 on 46% shooting his final series. People either forget about or didn't watch him in Denver and only remember the "cancer" he was in New York. At one time Carmelo was a LEGIT offensive threat.