Better Player: Hakeem or Duncan

[dankok8]

I've always been firmly in the Hakeem camp. Obviously Timmy is more accomplished but this is about who the better player is.

[Baller789]

I've always been firmly in the Hakeem camp. Obviously Timmy is more accomplished but this is about who the better player is.

At peak Hakeem.
Longevity its Duncan.

Overall its tough because one spent half his career as a PF.

[Round Mound]

Hakeem and its not close. Peak Hakeem is easily a Top 5 GOAT. Duncan also played more C than PF yet he is considered a PF! He was 6´11 ft and got outplayed by broken down old fat Barkley most times.

[SATAN]

Olajuwon. Shame he couldn't get more rings though.

[light]

the proof is in the pudding.

duncan is superior. and not just by a little bit.

hakeem played in weak era.

[SATAN]

Owning Shaq isn't what I'd call weak

[light]

Owning Shaq isn't what I'd call weak

owning any 21 year old player is weak sauce. thats not resume worthy. its not even worth mentioning.

[SATAN]

You're underestimating how dominant Shaq was as soon as he entered the league.

[light]

You're underestimating how dominant Shaq was as soon as he entered the league.

no im not. weak era applies to hakeem as much as mj. same reasons. and shaq didn't know what he was doing then.

[SATAN]

My contempt towards brainwashed MJ stans only goes so far, AlternativeAccount.

[JasonBailey]

Duncan is more experienced and more technical, but I think he will be better. Although both are quite professional.

[Baller789]

Hakeem and its not close. Peak Hakeem is easily a Top 5 GOAT. Duncan also played more C than PF yet he is considered a PF! He was 6´11 ft and got outplayed by broken down old fat Barkley most times.

If you just go by peak, I agree with you.
But you can't deny Duncan's positive effect on a franchise. Never missing the playoffs. Thats mighty impressive.

Look at the Spurs now.

[Reggie43]

I think Hakeem was better but you cant go wrong with picking either one.

[Bronbron23]

I've always been firmly in the Hakeem camp. Obviously Timmy is more accomplished but this is about who the better player is.

Hard to say tbh. Hakeem has a better peak but duncan has better longevity. Plus Hakeem was known to be difficult and not the greatest teammate early on in his career and duncan was great leader from jump.

Hakeem was probably the better player but duncan had the better career so gotta with duncan overall

[SouBeachTalents]

Such a predictable thread lol, everyone's gonna say Hakeem was the better player and Duncan had the better career