Higher All-Time: Elvin Hayes or Kevin McHale

[dankok8]

Who is higher all time?

[fsvr54]

This is an accomplishment vs actual skill battle

McHale was the better basketball player skill wise

[tontoz]

I was a Bullets fan back when Hayes was playing. Gotta go with McHale. Both guys were black holes but McHale was just better. Hayes relied heavily on a fadeaway jumper which isn't the most efficient shot. Not a popular guy in the locker room. Better rebounder but i think McHale was better at everything else.

McHale had so many moves in the post he was basically unguardable in spite of not being that strong or athletic. His length obviously helped. His length was close to Giannis.

[RRR3]

McHale.

[ImKobe]

Hayes had a terrible reputation as a teammate so I have to go with McHale.

[L.Kizzle]

It's crazy how fast people throw accolades out the door.

Hayes destroys him in ALL stats categories and accolades. Has scoring and rebounding titles.

[fsvr54]

Accolades, shmacolades...but is he a better player at the game of basketball?

[L.Kizzle]

Accolades, shmacolades...but is he a better player at the game of basketball?

How is he better when Hayes literally outdoes him at everything? More points, more blocks, more rebounds, even more assist and steals.
McHale was a better locker room guy and people hate Elvin.

[RRR3]

How is he better when Hayes literally outdoes him at everything? More points, more blocks, more rebounds, even more assist and steals.
McHale was a better locker room guy and people hate Elvin.

More points only because he chucked up way more shots lol.

[fsvr54]

How is he better when Hayes literally outdoes him at everything? More points, more blocks, more rebounds, even more assist and steals.
McHale was a better locker room guy and people hate Elvin.

McHale was a second or third option on stacked contenders. He has more basketball skill and acumen. Stats don't equate to being better.

[L.Kizzle]

More points only because he chucked up way more shots lol.

Kevin has ONE All NBA Team selection?

[RRR3]

Kevin has ONE All NBA Team selection?

So what? Hayes was a cancer who built mansions with all his bricks.

[L.Kizzle]

McHale was a second or third option on stacked contenders. He has more basketball skill and acumen. Stats don't equate to being better.

Don't forget he wasn't even a full time starter for only FOUR seasons.

[L.Kizzle]

So what? Hayes was a cancer who built mansions with all his bricks.

So accolades and stats only matter for certain players?

[RRR3]

So accolades and stats only matter for certain players?

McHale’s stats are better

I’m not impressed by points on shit efficiency.