Higher All-Time: Bill Walton or Anthony Davis

[dankok8]

Who's higher all time?

[RRR3]

Obviously AD. Walton barely played.

[FultzNationRISE]

The one who didnt need Lebron to change his damn diapers all the time.

[colts19]

To all of you who pick AD. I realize most people on this board aren't old enough to have seen a prime Bill Walton play, however, being old and having watched him play I can tell you that he was a special player and affected the game in ways that AD never has. Bill Russell was doing color on the game of the week and when asked what he thought of Walton said, "he reminds me of someone I coached once" of course referring to himself. Yea Bill was that great.

[SouBeachTalents]

To all of you who pick AD. I realize most people on this board aren't old enough to have seen a prime Bill Walton play, however, being old and having watched him play I can tell you that he was a special player and affected the game in ways that AD never has. Bill Russell was doing color on the game of the week and when asked what he thought of Walton said, "he reminds me of someone I coached once" of course referring to himself. Yea Bill was that great.

Nobody disputes he was great. The issue is his prime barely lasted 2 seasons. Even the year he won MVP he played only 58 games and was a literal non factor in the playoffs.

[RRR3]

To all of you who pick AD. I realize most people on this board aren't old enough to have seen a prime Bill Walton play, however, being old and having watched him play I can tell you that he was a special player and affected the game in ways that AD never has. Bill Russell was doing color on the game of the week and when asked what he thought of Walton said, "he reminds me of someone I coached once" of course referring to himself. Yea Bill was that great.

I’m aware Walton had more impact than Davis. But his prime lasted about 130 games.

[tontoz]

AD at age 28 has already played over 100 more games than Walton did in his whole career. Walton missed more games than he played.

[1987_Lakers]

Will this get as intense as the McHale/Hayes debate? lol

[fsvr54]

I’m aware Walton had more impact than Davis. But his prime lasted about 130 games.

So?

At one point he was a better player than AD will ever be. So he's a better all time player

[RRR3]

So?

At one point he was a better player than AD will ever be. So he's a better all time player

Then he should be ranked over Isiah Thomas by this logic.

[fsvr54]

If he was indeed better, then yeah.

[RRR3]

If he was indeed better, then yeah.

Damn I guess you must have Jokic in the top 25 then.

[fsvr54]

I don't have personal rankings, nor care to.

[L.Kizzle]

Will this get as intense as the McHale/Hayes debate? lol

I'm not to high in both. AD vs McHale is a good debate tho.

[HBK_Kliq_2]

I would say about even but Davis is clearly on pace to pass him.