Mahomes is the 2nd best athlete ever next to lebron

[AirBonner]

He is another Aaron Fraudgers. One hit wonder.

Not saying he’s a fraud yet but dude just wasted a golden opportunity with his stacked offense

[warriorfan]

MaGOAT 3 drives, 3 TD's. 1 incompletion.

Bout to be 3 straight SB trips for the GOAT. Should've been 4 straight.

[AlternativeAcc.]

Inching closer to number 1.

2 MVPS, 2SB MVPS, 5 straight division titles in 5 years as starter.

Statistically by far the best in both regular and post season.


Greatest start to a career in sports history.

[ArbitraryWater]

Mahomes ain’t close to Brady

He is another Aaron Fraudgers. One hit wonder.

[John8204]

Eh...I really don't rank Mahomes as one of the greatest athletes of all-time especially in football when you had JJ Watt, Lawrence Taylor, Deon Sanders, and Jim Brown.

Lebron on the other hand might be the greatest athlete of all-time but Wilt Chamberlain is up there and I give John Stockton a lot of credit for his conditioning and cardio.

In baseball you've got Jackie Robinson, Babe Ruth (underrated), Rickey Henderson, and Ichiro Suzuki

And then you've got Jim Thorpe, Hershel Walker, and Bo Jackson who you likely have to rank.

[1987_Lakers]

Eh...I really don't rank Mahomes as one of the greatest athletes of all-time especially in football when you had JJ Watt, Lawrence Taylor, Deon Sanders, and Jim Brown.

Lebron on the other hand might be the greatest athlete of all-time but Wilt Chamberlain is up there and I give John Stockton a lot of credit for his conditioning and cardio.

In baseball you've got Jackie Robinson, Babe Ruth (underrated), Rickey Henderson, and Ichiro Suzuki

And then you've got Jim Thorpe, Hershel Walker, and Bo Jackson who you likely have to rank.

Babe Ruth is far from underrated. I think he was named greatest Athlete of the 20th century by AP and he is still discussed all the time despite playing 100 years ago which is pretty crazy when you think about it.

Mahomes to me is the most talented QB the NFL has ever seen and QB is by for the most important/impactful position in football. Only thing missing is the longevity, but he will get there.

[AlternativeAcc.]

Babe Ruth is far from underrated. I think he was named greatest Athlete of the 20th century by AP and he is still discussed all the time despite playing 100 years ago which is pretty crazy when you think about it.

Mahomes to me is the most talented QB the NFL has ever seen and QB is by for the most important/impactful position in football. Only thing missing is the longevity, but he will get there.

This guy is clearly talking about just pure athleticism and yet somehow inserts babe Ruth. And John Stockton who was a 6ft white dude who couldn't jump 2 feet in the air...

Hmmm. Pretty interesting post.

[SouBeachTalents]

This guy is clearly talking about just pure athleticism and yet somehow inserts babe Ruth. And John Stockton who was a 6ft white dude who couldn't jump 2 feet in the air...

Hmmm. Pretty interesting post.

That's the same guy who has Shaq 25th all time.

[John8204]

This guy is clearly talking about just pure athleticism and yet somehow inserts babe Ruth. And John Stockton who was a 6ft white dude who couldn't jump 2 feet in the air...

Hmmm. Pretty interesting post.

Well what do you classify as "athleticism", Ruth was able to hit, run, and pitch and Stoctkon's cardio was insane along with his durability to maintain that for 19 seasons.

That's the same guy who has Shaq 25th all time.

Was Shaq athletic? Or was he just fat and big. Also you keep bringing this up but you've never addressed the multiple issues I have with Shaq and his career. Shaq is also top 25 not 25th I rank below Hakeem who actually was athletic

[Gohan]

That's the same guy who has Shaq 25th all time.

You cant always question a man’s credibility because of their bias(in his case hes hating on shaq a little too hard for my taste)

[PP34Deuce]

Joe Montana said he's a freak of nature. He's in the Steve Young Brett Favre Aaron rodgers Elway archtype...

He maintains a lot of their characteristics but is much smarter with the ball and adjustments than them at the same age.

You want a 20 yard run.. mahomes can do that
You want a shootout...mahomes can do that
You want dink and dunk. .mahomes can do that.

He's a nurtured aaron rodgers with a better attitude and slightly more athletic. Alex Smith and Andy Reid vs mccarthy and favre....

[ArbitraryWater]

Eh...I really don't rank Mahomes as one of the greatest athletes of all-time especially in football when you had JJ Watt, Lawrence Taylor, Deon Sanders, and Jim Brown.

Lebron on the other hand might be the greatest athlete of all-time but Wilt Chamberlain is up there and I give John Stockton a lot of credit for his conditioning and cardio.

In baseball you've got Jackie Robinson, Babe Ruth (underrated), Rickey Henderson, and Ichiro Suzuki

And then you've got Jim Thorpe, Hershel Walker, and Bo Jackson who you likely have to rank.

wtf? Hahahahaha

[Wally450]

Mahomes is on the trajectory to be the greatest of all time. I'm curious to see what the next 4-5 years look like.

[ArbitraryWater]

Well what do you classify as "athleticism", Ruth was able to hit, run, and pitch and Stoctkon's cardio was insane along with his durability to maintain that for 19 seasons.



Was Shaq athletic? Or was he just fat and big. Also you keep bringing this up but you've never addressed the multiple issues I have with Shaq and his career. Shaq is also top 25 not 25th I rank below Hakeem who actually was athletic

goat athete(s) isnt someone with good athetic ability but how good they are at playing, dumbass.

[bullettooth]

Are Bran stans stupid across the board for all sports?