Amare Stoudemire or Dwight Howard?

[baseketball4life]

Why do people feel the need to post in thread with 1 liners? If you want to contribute how bout you explain yourself even if its just a small explanation? Not to mention people dont read these threads to see whats already been said/argued.

Amare Stoudemire is better than Dwight Howard in my opinion

Amare's ability to create his own shot, finish around the rim, hit his free throws, hit the jumper, and use all of the moves he's got (he has more moves than Dwight) puts him over Dwight. Even though Dwight is the better rebounder and shot blocker/post defender, I'd take Amare anyday and everyday

[WildStyle]

Ok, then answer this...

If you are Orlando, would you trade Dwight for Amare if the opportunity presented itself?

[WildStyle]

There is not one Magic fan on earth who would trade Dwight for Amare. I'm sure you could find some Suns fans that would though. That tells me a lot.

[U got Served]

I wouldn't trade Howard for Amare. Howard is a much better player.

[omarnyc]

Ok, then answer this...

If you are Orlando, would you trade Dwight for Amare if the opportunity presented itself?

of course orlando is not gonna trade their young center for a pf, all-star centers are rare

[highwhey]

There is not one Magic fan on earth who would trade Dwight for Amare. I'm sure you could find some Suns fans that would though. That tells me a lot.

Dwight wouldn't fit with the current Suns system. Don't give me that bs that he has speed...he doesn't have enough speed, nor is he athletically superior like Amare. People are overrating his D, yes he has excellent defense. Although the gap between his D is nothing like Amare's Offensive advantage.

[U got Served]

Dwight wouldn't fit with the current Suns system. Don't give me that bs that he has speed...he doesn't have enough speed, nor is he athletically superior like Amare. People are overrating his D, yes he has excellent defense. Although the gap between his D is nothing like Amare's Offensive advantage.

Howard is Orlando's franchise player. If you're assuming Amare could take his spot you're crazy.

[omarnyc]

There is not one Magic fan on earth who would trade Dwight for Amare. I'm sure you could find some Suns fans that would though. That tells me a lot.

making trades dont determine if a player is better then the other, thats the dumbest **** i've read on here, if we go by your logic al jefferson is better then kg, kwame brown is better then caron butler and pau gasol, we can go on and on

[highwhey]

Howard is Orlando's franchise player. If you're assuming Amare could take his spot you're crazy.

when did I say that? Amare is Suns franchise player...Kerr is building around him. No way D12 would fit here...well not with the style they've been playing with.

[omarnyc]

when did I say that? Amare is Suns franchise player...Kerr is building around him. No way D12 would fit here...well not with the style they've been playing with.

these cats really think you can just stick a player , especially a center, on any team and get the same results.

[statman32]

There is not one Magic fan on earth who would trade Dwight for Amare. I'm sure you could find some Suns fans that would though. That tells me a lot.

What does that tell you? That Dwight is younger and less injury prone because it sure as hell doesnt tell you that Dwight is better than Amare right now.

[final.wrath]

yao is the best right now of the three but hes also a lot older and can only play the halfcourt style offense and is best as a #1 option.

dwight is younger, a better rebounder, and a better defender than amare. all he needs is to develop a better offensive game and then he has a shot at being one of the great big men of all time.

[U got Served]

when did I say that? Amare is Suns franchise player...Kerr is building around him. No way D12 would fit here...well not with the style they've been playing with.

\

What I'm trying to say is that Amare is not a franchise guy and he can't be no matter which team he's with. Howard is and will be a franchise player in any team he's with. this might of gotten of topic but i stick with the opinion that Howard is better than Amare.

[BrianScalabrine]

Dwight, because Amare is delusional.

[highwhey]

\

What I'm trying to say is that Amare is not a franchise guy and he can't be no matter which team he's with. Howard is and will be a franchise player in any team he's with. this might of gotten of topic but i stick with the opinion that Howard is better than Amare.

your opinion isn't relevant, facts are. what you've claimed is not a fact.