Week 17 Discussion Thread

[-p.tiddy-]

first off Marino isn't in the GOAT disscussion at all...Montana, Peyton, Brady all >>> and a few others are arguable

second I DIDN'T put Romo's name in the same sentence, you did

third:

and he's taken his team to the playoffs 10 times while romo at 33 has only taken dallas to the playoffs 3 times

fourth Romo was better than Luck during the regular season, and you would agree if they weren't in the playoffs...all you see is TEAM wins...there is no stat that Luck was better than Romo in this year, you HAVE to use wins to make your argument

[-p.tiddy-]

This is rmo best year in terms of yardage and pass attempts with nearly 100 more passing attempts than Marino's best year in yardage and still didn't pass him up yardage or even got close to his TDs.

and with a passer rating of 90.0

this was Romo's WORST year ever

[Pacers4ever]

Originally Posted by -p.tiddy-

first off Marino isn't in the GOAT disscussion at all...Montana, Peyton, Brady all >>> and a few others are arguable

second I DIDN'T put Romo's name in the same sentence, you did

third:





fourth Romo was better than Luck during the regular season, and you would agree if they weren't in the playoffs...all you see is TEAM wins...there is no stat that Luck was better than Romo in this year, you HAVE to use wins to make your argument

Are you ****ing drunk? Where in bold did I state any of those, or say romo didn't have a better season than luck? Reading comprehension use it.

[Jackass18]

Originally Posted by -p.tiddy-

that everyone views wins and loses as a QB stat with the exception of Marino for some reason...

Only 1 losing season in his career. Went to a SB in his 2nd season. His defense and running game was generally somewhere in the 20s. Not that I rank QBs by wins and losses, but it's a part of it. I place much less value on it than a lot do. I don't know why you're saying "with the exception for Marino" for, though. Not winning a SB is always brought up when his name comes up. "...but, he didn't win a Super Bowl."

same should be done with QBs today IMO...I'm so sick of what seems to be 95% of NFL fans ranking QBs by wins and loses...there are 52 other fcking players on the team

Uh, isn't that why you rank Montana so highly?

first off Marino isn't in the GOAT disscussion at all...Montana, Peyton, Brady all >>> and a few others are arguable

The **** are you talking about? Of course Marino is in the discussion.

[Carbine]

Luck has a better Total QBR and the most game winning drives by a quarterback in all of a football.

[AlonzoGOAT]

Originally Posted by Jackass18

Only 1 losing season in his career. Went to a SB in his 2nd season. His defense and running game was generally somewhere in the 20s. Not that I rank QBs by wins and losses, but it's a part of it. I place much less value on it than a lot do. I don't know why you're saying "with the exception for Marino" for, though. Not winning a SB is always brought up when his name comes up. "...but, he didn't win a Super Bowl."



Uh, isn't that why you rank Montana so highly?



The **** are you talking about? Of course Marino is in the discussion.

I agree with everything you said and the arguments but even tho I'm a biased dolphin fan I can admit that he can't compare to tom brady and montana because rings are just a huge factor to general fans but he will always be my favorite/greatest QB and I think he is the GOAT QB from a pure talent standpoint but that's just my opinion. I miss Marino he was like my Porn in the good old days Hopefully tannehill (QB in my avy) can end this drought of bad QBs since my marino.