Simple, rate 1-5. I mainly am talking about CURRENT players, but I reckon you could post past players as well.
1 - Horrible, why is this guy even a pro?
2 - He sucks, expect him to be traded a lot.
3 - Good player, he helps with the teams success. Not quite a HOF contender.
4 - Great player, he could be a MVP, and help take his team to the Super Bowl, possibly a HOF contender.
5 - Amazing player. His number will be retired and he is headed to the HOF without a doubt.
I'm going to start off
Aaron Rodgers, QB for Green Bay Packers