Dirk or Kobe, All Time?

[BigKAT]

Oh my goodness!

What's their career playoffs h2h btw?

I think Duncan has a better h2h vs Lebron.

I still have Lebron ranked higher.

So yeah.

[Young X]

In what was is 9-27 close to 6-24? Stop hating, fool

The point is they were both bad and got bailed out in their closeout games.

Dirk was like 1-11 in the first half or some shit and the only thing that kept Dallas in the game was Terry.

I'm not saying which one was better but you can't mention one without the other.

[Sarcastic]

Dirk is top 25, borderline top 20 tier.

Kobe is well ahead of that tier.

[Bankaii]

This is getting ridiculous.

Even if you somehow hate Kobe to the core, at the very worst he's top 11.
Dirk has no argument for top 15. None at all.

[ArbitraryWater]

The point is they were both bad and got bailed out in their closeout games.

Dirk was like 1-11 in the first half or some shit and the only thing that kept Dallas in the game was Terry.

I'm not saying which one was better but you can't mention one without the other.

One is demonstrably worse, so yeah you kinda can.. check out Naero's post for some of the finer details.

[JT123]

What's their playoff h2h folks?

Thanks

Kobe stans still avoiding this question like the plague

[Doranku]

What's LeBron's h2h with Timmy?

[J Shuttlesworth]

This is getting ridiculous.

Even if you somehow hate Kobe to the core, at the very worst he's top 11.
Dirk has no argument for top 15. None at all.

This

[Mr Feeny]

The point is they were both bad and got bailed out in their closeout games.

Dirk was like 1-11 in the first half or some shit and the only thing that kept Dallas in the game was Terry.

I'm not saying which one was better but you can't mention one without the other.

The point is one is worse than the other. That's the comparison.
As a.w. said, one is demonstrably worse. Case closed.

This isn't rocket science.

[ArbitraryWater]

Its so close between the two..

2000: Draw
2001: Kobe
2002: Draw
2003: Draw
2004: Dirk
2005: Dirk by a mile
2006: Dirk
2007: Draw
2008: Kobe
2009: Draw
2010: Dirk
2011: Dirk
2012: Draw
2013: Kobe
2014: Dirk by a MILE
2015: Dirk by a MILE
2016: Dirk by a MILE

[Mr Feeny]

Kobe stans still avoiding this question like the plague

[JT123]

Its so close between the two..

2000: Draw
2001: Kobe
2002: Draw
2003: Draw
2004: Dirk
2005: Dirk by a mile
2006: Dirk
2007: Draw
2008: Kobe
2009: Draw
2010: Dirk
2011: Dirk
2012: Draw
2013: Kobe
2014: Dirk by a MILE
2015: Dirk by a MILE
2016: Dirk by a MILE

Holy shit Kobe was only better than Dirk during 3 seasons?!
Looks like my idol is now 13be

[GrapeApe]

Dirk's 2011 playoff run as a whole was all-time great, but his finals performance IS a bit overrated. If Lebron shows up in the 4th quarter, the Heat probably sweep the series. I'd still give him a slight edge over 2010 Kobe, but saying that Kobe was better is not as outlandish as it might appear on the surface.

[BigKAT]

Holy shit Kobe was only better than Dirk during 3 seasons?!
Looks like my idol is now 13be

You are an elegant soul.
I can see the pain you go through, yet you're still so humble in recognizing your Idol is not perfect.

[Sarcastic]

Kobe stans still avoiding this question like the plague

Curry is 7-6 vs Lebron, so he's better?