Is KD better than prime TMac?

[knicksman]

Perhaps I should go back to the overrated players tread and add T-Mac. Durant is better. What are you T-Mac pickers basing your choice on?

their IQ

[Alan Ogg]

Durant's last two seasons alone have been better than any T-Mac season. In addition, the highest T-Mac got in MVP voting was 4th twice and had a couple 1st all NBA team selections. Durant already has placed 2nd in MVP voting three times and 5th and on his way to an MVP along with 4 1st all NBA team selections and a 5th coming this year. Durant is only 25 years old. This is not close.

[gts]

Perhaps I should go back to the overrated players tread and add T-Mac. Durant is better. What are you T-Mac pickers basing your choice on?

They don't like Durant

[Cold soul]

It's a close call, but I give the slight edge to T-Mac.

[Fire Colangelo]

Durant's last two seasons alone have been better than any T-Mac season. In addition, the highest T-Mac got in MVP voting was 4th twice and had a couple 1st all NBA team selections. Durant already has placed 2nd in MVP voting three times and 5th and on his way to an MVP along with 4 1st all NBA team selections and a 5th coming this year. Durant is only 25 years old. This is not close.

Do you think durant would be 2nd in MVP if his team was a shitty as Tmac's back in 03? McGrady's career was robbed of injuries but he was scary good in 03.

[Ancient Legend]

Who would have a better chance at the Hall of Fame between T-Mac and Durant if KD's career ended now?

[Ratnik]

Is your dick bigger than a black man's?
No.

[SilkkTheShocker]

Tmac was a loser.

Durant is a crying ass bitch

Give me LeBron.

[Hamtaro CP3KDKG]

KDs prime is way better. Peak was a debate in 2012 KD vs 03 TMac but it hasnt been a debate this season and the last. KDs been far better.

[oarabbus]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i3jTaT3pYFE

Such a sick move. Sh1tty vid though.

[kuniva_dAMiGhTy]

On his shooting alone, KD is more dangerous, ergo better.

[Embers]

Is your next mind bender, Is Wilt Chamberlain better then Kendrick Perkins?

[bizil]

For me, I gotta give the edge to T-Mac. Just as dominant a scorer, and could do everything just as good or better than Durant in terms of scoring EXCEPT for the three ball. And T-Mac was even a very good at times great three ball shooter. T-Mac was also a great all around player while Durant is a very good one. U could go either way, but I would roll with peak T-Mac at his point. Peak wise, the only SG's I would take over T-Mac are MJ and Kobe! I actually see shades of T-Mac big time in Durant. In terms of smooth scorers who have epic scoring skillsets, Gervin, T-Mac, and Durant take that shit!!

[Bigsmoke]

Durant is better.

Tmac is more smooth... OK cool.

Durant is much more efficient, better rebounder, better to depend on in the postseason.

[IGOTGAME]

Durant just isnt a good passer or playmaker. You will see when it matter, only thing is that you will blame it on everyone else. He just has zero feel for it. He is a scorer and rebounder on offense, passing just isnt his thing. He has gotten a little better but it doesnt come easy to him.