American Idols versus Legends...Who's Better by Group?

[Dnn111]

Males
Legends
Al Green
Michael Jackson
Marvin Gaye
Ray Charles
Sam Cooke
Otis Redding
Clyde McPhatter
Jackie Wilson
Curtis Mayfield
Percy Mayfield
Smokey Robinson


versus...

American Idols
Ruben Studdard
Clay Aiken
Taylor Hicks
Sanjaya Malakar...He's the Indian guy in this years show (2007)
Chris Daughtry
Justin Guarini
Elliott Yamin
George Huff
Scott Savol
Constantine Marioules
Ace Young

now for the...

Females
Legends
Aretha Franklin
Mahalia Jackson
Whitney Houston
Diana Ross
Dionne Warrick
Mariah Carey
Toni Braxton
Patti LaBelle
Etta James
Dusty Springfield

American Idols
Kelly Clarkson
Fantasia Barrino
Carrie Underwood
Diana DeGarmo
Katherine McPhee
Jennifer Hudson
Kellie Pickler
Lisa Tucker
Paris Bennett
LaToya London
Tamyra Gray


P.S. Finally...who makes or has better music... Bob Dylan or Kelly Clarkson

[WuTangWizard]

You actually remember American Idol's from past years who didn't win?