2014 Edition of ISH's All-Time List: #9 (REDO)

[ArbitraryWater]

I'm counting 9.

Me/Cocaine/OrlandoMagic/RoundMound/BasedTom/Heatles/Freeman/zoom/BernieNips/MilkyBarKid... Although yea, if you dont count Heatles, then 9.. Which makes more sense.

[DaSeba5]

Me/Cocaine/OrlandoMagic/RoundMound/BasedTom/Heatles/Freeman/zoom/BernieNips/MilkyBarKid... Although yea, if you dont count Heatles, then 9.. Which makes more sense.

Ok. As long as I have people helping me with the voting count because it's hard to keep track then it should be smooth from here.

[Riley Martin]

Between Hakeem and Kobe.. mmm I'll say Kobe.

[DaSeba5]

Between Hakeem and Kobe.. mmm I'll say Kobe.

Sorry you need 1000 posts.

[Milbuck]

What is the point of this? Just keep the one that already exists open..

[ArbitraryWater]

What is the point of this? Just keep the one that already exists open..

A troll-fest with 10+ alts and no rules, led by russwest? Naw..

[fpliii]

Nah can't count him... 400 Posts since 2011.. Never seen the guy before.. Obvious alt

Riley used to post on ESPN and I know him from another board, not an alt. He's a Heat fan fwiw.

[Milbuck]

A troll-fest with 10+ alts and no rules, led by russwest? Naw..

The whole issue was closing the thread too early..so just keep that one open. It's not like the voting was close anyways, Kobe had more votes than Lebron and Hakeem combined. And how are we to determine who is an alt?

[fpliii]

A troll-fest with 10+ alts and no rules, led by russwest? Naw..

To be fair, we're gonna end up with two lists now. russwest0's with Kobe-LeBron going 9-10, and this one with LeBron-Kobe going 9-10. Hakeem, KG, Oscar, etc. don't have enough supporters to move the needle.

Don't have an issue with it, just an observation.

[ArbitraryWater]

Riley used to post on ESPN and I know him from another board, not an alt. He's a Heat fan fwiw.

Yea but we could say this for everyone.. Need a strict rule.. And frankly, just because you know him from ESPN, doesn't really mean he's not one.. Not trying to be disrespectful or anything.

[ArbitraryWater]

The whole issue was closing the thread too early..so just keep that one open. It's not like the voting was close anyways, Kobe had more votes than Lebron and Hakeem combined. And how are we to determine who is an alt?

Well I doubt any alt will have 1000 or even 500 Posts.. So actually it might be easier than you think.

[fpliii]

Yea but we could say this for everyone.. Need a strict rule.. And frankly, just because you know him from ESPN, doesn't really mean he's not one.. Not trying to be disrespectful or anything.

Yeah, that's fine if you don't want to set a bad precedent/open up the floodgates.

[robert de niro]

since this thread has no credibility whatsoever, brandon jennings

[Milbuck]

Well I doubt any alt will have 1000 or even 500 Posts.. So actually it might be easier than you think.

Lurkers exist, but whatever. Just continue with that thread considering there are so many votes already there that are most likely going to be discounted from posters who 1) might not come back to see the re-do, and 2) posters who don't want to re-vote. Start your sub-500 post rule in that thread.

[ArbitraryWater]

LeBron is in the lead with mostly green bar posters voting, an objective OP and finally some fair rules = no credibility >>> kobe fans