Michael Vick is such a unique talent.

[niko]

The defense made all of that possible. It's not like the Giants were outgunning people 41-40 and shit like that, the defense shut those teams down. How hard is that for you to see? The defense closed two of those games out with INT's(dallas and GB) while completely shutting down the Pats and Buccaneers.

He drove his team down the field with 2 minutes left against the best team in the league (18-0 team at the time) to win the Superbowl. You can't say automatically Michael Vick would have done the same.

Kevin Kolb would have beaten Detroit. Therefore, he was as good as Vick and should start. Doesn't matter that he didn't actually do that, since we are arguing on supposition.

[PowerGlove]

He drove his team down the field with 2 minutes left against the best team in the league (18-0 team at the time) to win the Superbowl. You can't say automatically Michael Vick would have done the same.

Kevin Kolb would have beaten Detroit. Therefore, he was as good as Vick and should start. Doesn't matter that he didn't actually do that, since we are arguing on supposition.

You remember that spin move where Vick eluded the pass rusher? Kevin Kolb would have be dead. He would have looked like Trent Green.

He had one drive, and no I can't say Vick would have done the same thing but you can't automatically assume he wouldn't.

[niko]

You remember that spin move where Vick eluded the pass rusher? Kevin Kolb would have be dead. He would have looked like Trent Green.

He had one drive, and no I can't say Vick would have done the same thing but you can't automatically assume he wouldn't.

The quote i was arguing with was the person saying VICK WOULD HAVE DONE THE SAME AND LED THE GIANTS TO THE SUPERBOWL. Not it's a possibility, that it would have happened. If you don't think it's 100% the case i'm not sure why you are even commenting.

And i was being fasciteous, you don't wnat to give Eli credit for what he did, i'm just pointing out how easy it is to twist facts that way (with couldve's and maybes)

[Fatal9]

Philly newspaper...

[niko]

Philly newspaper...

[NoGunzJustSkillz]

One, they werent a running team and how are you going to use a player who only played two season with Vick as an example?

fck that, roddy white was the sh!t them 2 seasons [COLOR="White"]in madden[/COLOR].

[O.J A 6'4Mamba]

Philly newspaper...

classless. and I am a Vick Fan, how can the editor allowed a title " Top Dog" to be publish.

[niko]

We should post a "Discuss MIchael Vick's performance" thread when the game is over Sunday to replace this.

[niko]

It's amazing how much neg rep i get from not being a rah rah Vick supporter.

[PowerGlove]

It's amazing how much neg rep i get from not being a rah rah Vick supporter.

I'm getting neg rep from this thread too. Someone is just insecure.

[niko]

I'm getting neg rep from this thread too. Someone is just insecure.

Oops, sorry for doing that. jk...

I love the negs with the hateful message. I also like how many people insult the girl in my avi like i posted a picture of my wife or something. **** YOU AND YOUR AVI YOU ASSHOLE! VICK FOREVER!

[boozehound]

I negged you all for acting like children! [COLOR="White"]Not really, but you were acting like children. [/COLOR]

[niko]

I negged you all for acting like children! [COLOR="White"]Not really, but you were acting like children. [/COLOR]

that's allowed under the ISH bylaws i believe. sometimes i feel its encouraged.

[O.J A 6'4Mamba]

Who was the poster who said he rather have Eli Manning over Michael Vick
My next question is, will Pryor be better than Vick?

[Mr Clutch Melo]

Might be stupid question, but I just started watch NFL ( My second game o)

When does a QB enter his prime ? Vick is 30 and still killing despite losing almost 2 years