Top 100: NFL's Greatest Players

[boozehound]

did you see nate Newton got the stomach surgury done?





doesn't even look like him at all...







he lost 135 lbs...

how weird is that? A dude who still weighs 265 looks like a cancer survivor.

[Jackass18]

I remember Nate Newton because he got busted with about 200lbs of marijuana.

Moss is much better than Irvin. Irvin might not even be a top 10 WR.

[steve]

Bump...next 10.

90. Kurt Warner
89. Ernie Nevers
88. Ed Reed
87. Crazylegs Hirsch
86. Willie Davis
85. Marcus Allen
84. Joe Schmidt
83. Norm Van Brocklin
82. Ted Hendricks
81. Steve Young

[Timmy D for MVP]

Steve Young at 81 was too low.

I may be biased cause he's my favorite player of all time. But damn...

[Dasher]

Steve Young at 81 was too low.

I may be biased cause he's my favorite player of all time. But damn...

Steve won one Superbowl and had a very short prime. I would not include him, Joe Namath, or Try Aikman in a top 100 list.

[-playmaker-]

how weird is that? A dude who still weighs 265 looks like a cancer survivor.

his bones probably weigh 200 lbs alone...

he can use "I'm big boned" as a legit excuse...lol

[-playmaker-]

Steve won one Superbowl and had a very short prime. I would not include him, Joe Namath, or Try Aikman in a top 100 list.

Namath...alright

Young and Aikman off a top 100 list is completely insane...

[Sarcastic]

Steve won one Superbowl and had a very short prime. I would not include him, Joe Namath, or Try Aikman in a top 100 list.

He also won 2 MVPs, a SB MVP, set a record in that SB with 6 passing TDs, and has the highest QB rating of all time. If he didn't sit backup to Montana for so long, he would have ended up in the top 50 I think.

[Dasher]

He also won 2 MVPs, a SB MVP, set a record in that SB with 6 passing TDs, and has the highest QB rating of all time. If he didn't sit backup to Montana for so long, he would have ended up in the top 50 I think.

He has a similar profile to Kurt Warner who will possibly not make this list. QB rating is a dubious stat because it is skewed for the modern era and is does not accurately account for the dominance or lack thereof of the passers of yesteryear.

[-playmaker-]

[COLOR="Red"]He has a similar profile to Kurt Warner who will possibly not make this list. [/COLOR]QB rating is a dubious stat because it is skewed for the modern era and is does not accurately account for the dominance or lack thereof of the passers of yesteryear.

[COLOR="Red"]90. Kurt Warner[/COLOR]
89. Ernie Nevers
88. Ed Reed
87. Crazylegs Hirsch
86. Willie Davis
85. Marcus Allen
84. Joe Schmidt
83. Norm Van Brocklin
82. Ted Hendricks
81. Steve Young

[Dasher]

Touche prime. I also would not put Ed Reed on the list. Is he really better than Darren Woodson who will not make this list?

[-playmaker-]

Touche prime. I also would not put Ed Reed on the list. Is he really better than Darren Woodson who will not make this list?

Reed is more dominate than Woodson ever was, that being said Woodson is very underrated as player in general...

I bet Dawkins makes the list and Woodson is probably better or just as good than Dawk ever was...

[steve]

He has a similar profile to Kurt Warner who will possibly not make this list. QB rating is a dubious stat because it is skewed for the modern era and is does not accurately account for the dominance or lack thereof of the passers of yesteryear.

Sure it does, you just have to adjust for the era that they were playing in and see how it's comparable to their contemporaries.

[Da KO King]

Why am I having trouble accepting someone ranked Tom Brady 14th greatest player in NFL history?

Because accepting that would mean being fine with Walter Payton at #22 and Gale Sayers in the 80's.

[Jackass18]

Bump...next 10.

90. Kurt Warner
89. Ernie Nevers
88. Ed Reed
87. Crazylegs Hirsch
86. Willie Davis
85. Marcus Allen
84. Joe Schmidt
83. Norm Van Brocklin
82. Ted Hendricks
81. Steve Young

This seems so random. It doesn't look like there's any rhyme or reason to it.