Chris Paul or Jason Kidd?

[sammichoffate]

Jason Kidd is the best PG since Stockton and Magic

[Fire Colangelo]

Jason Kidd is the best PG since Stockton and Magic

Depends whether or not you consider Robertson a PG. I'd take Isiah over anyone not named Oscar and Magic for my PG.

[MiseryCityTexas]

Kidd

[JohnFreeman]

[houston]

kidd of course

[Fire Colangelo]

CP3's mini run in 08 is underrated. Watch the games and tell me he wouldn't do the same with those nets in the shitty eastern conference.

[TheMarkMadsen]

Jason Kidd is the best PG since Stockton and Magic

Isiah >>>>> Stockton

[steve]

Here are Jason Kidd's playoff numbers before he turned 28 (keep in mind that at this point in his career his team had won a single playoff series, one that he only played a single game in): 12.6 points per game, 9.9 assists 3.1 turnovers on 38% shooting from the floor and 29% from three (while taking nearly 4 threes a game) and a playoff record of 6-17.

[k0kakw0rld]

Kidd was a triple double threat every night.

Better player
better defender
better offensive player
better passer
better vision
better floor general
better rebounder
better at almost everything except maybe 3 pt shooting?

Kidd is the GOAT PG.\

Magic was a point forward.
Stockton is a close 2nd

[Fire Colangelo]

Kidd was a triple double threat every night.

Better player
better defender
better offensive player
better passer
better vision
better floor general
better rebounder
better at almost everything except maybe 3 pt shooting?

Kidd is the GOAT PG.\

Magic was a point forward.
Stockton is a close 2nd

What in the world

Kidd is not a better offensive player, Paul is a better scorer. Passing/vision/floor General is a wash, slight edge to Kidd. But Paul's scoring give him the edge offensively.

[Milbuck]

Honestly, I'd take CP3 from 2007-2009 over Kidd.

[k0kakw0rld]

What in the world

Kidd is not a better offensive player, Paul is a better scorer. Passing/vision/floor General is a wash, slight edge to Kidd. But Paul's scoring give him the edge offensively.

Offense is not always about scoring my friend. Give prime Kidd the roster Paul has right now he will be averaging at least 16-18 APG. Kidd's biggest weakness was his shooting ability, especially the three. He amazingly improved in that area throughout his entire career. He was for me the perfect Point guard. 6'4 could guard 3 positions. He could control the tempo of a game like no other. He led a 2002 Nets to a ECF championship but lost to the finals vs Lakers.

Something CP3 will never do.

[ZMonkey11]

Isiah >>>>> Stockton

Ah thank you.

[JohnFreeman]

[Fire Colangelo]

Offense is not always about scoring my friend. Give prime Kidd the roster Paul has right now he will be averaging at least 16-18 APG. Kidd's biggest weakness was his shooting ability, especially the three. He amazingly improved in that area throughout his entire career. He was for me the perfect Point guard. 6'4 could guard 3 positions. He could control the tempo of a game like no other. He led a 2002 Nets to a ECF championship but lost to the finals vs Lakers.

Something CP3 will never do.

Scoring is a big part of offense, CP3 makes the defense respect him because he can drop 30 any night, that's a big part of offense.

Kidd would not average 16-18APG, that's absurd.

He's a great defender, I've acknowledged that.

Actually Kidd's worst weakness was his inability to score in general.

Rewatch the 2008 playoffs, you don't think 08 Paul can do the same with the Nets in a much weaker conference?