Should I do Garcia+Caron Butler+Barbosa for Nash?

[brantonli]

My roster as it stands

Duhon
Nash
Chris Paul
Brooks
Harden
Calderon
Okafor
Ariza
Scola
Miller
Camby
Griffin


As you can see, I've got quite a few PGs, but right now Garcia and Barbosa are injured.
I'm currently 7-0-0 in threes, 6-1-0 in assists, 5-2-0 in FT%, but 4-3-0 or 3-4-0 in all the other categories.

[sportin_life]

Should I do Garcia+Caron Butler+Barbosa for Nash?

My roster as it stands

Duhon
Nash
Chris Paul
Brooks
Harden
Calderon
Okafor
Ariza
Scola
Miller
Camby
Griffin

Is this Francisco Garcia you're talking about??? I would definitely take that trade b/c Garcia has almost no value. Barbosa has close to no value (he has played horribly even before he was injured) and Butler has been playing horrible this season.

The Nash side wins out big time. It won't help in your other cats, but you would have arguably the 2 best PG's in fantasy and try to fill in your holes through the waiver or make more trades for some solid bigs. Or you can always re-trade Nash and land a round 1-2 big man.

[benJAMin]

I'd stay put. You do realize that adding Garcia and Barbosa means you have to drop two of your current players? I'd say Harden is your only player worth dropping, and you might be better off with him than Garcia anyway. Considering the dropoff in stats from Nash to Caron, coupled with the fact that you would more or less downgrade from Harden/Griffin to Garcia/Barbosa, you should stay far away from making the deal.

[D.Z.W.]

No way would I give up Nash for those three.

[sportin_life]

Oops I misread the trade and thought you were getting Nash. I still stand that the Nash side wins big, but I thought you were getting him as opposed to giving him up.