I just don't buy wins over top Big East teams as being quality. The Big East teams are overrated, play a weak schedule, then beat each other, who were ranked too high, and then use that as justification.
Do either Rutgers/Louisville/WV have a non conference top 25 win? Just top 25, I'm not even asking for a Top 10 or 15.
All I know is that I really don't want to see a UofM/OSU rematch for the national championship. That could potentially lead to both teams finishing the year 11-1, and tied in the head to head matchup. That's a horrible way to end the year IMO. Without a playoff system, I don't believe in college football rematches.