Very tough call, both were dominant pass rushing DTs. Honestly dont know.
I agree....and yes, I'm a Bucs fan. John Randle was a freaking beast. But so was Sapp. If I were an extremely homer/biased fan, I'd say Sapp no doubt. But its very close. Two of the top DTs ever though, no doubt.
Randle was probably better longevity-wise, but for a good 4-year stretch, Sapp was a complete beast.
I just wanted to emphasize the fact that since i'm a Bucs fan, that my saying its equal really shows how great Randle was. Majority of people who has a player on his favorite team would automatically say "my player".