Make a list and see if you can put him in the top 10. Would you put him ahead of Roddy, Smith, or Boldin?
I could put him ahead of Boldin but that's just me. He's been as consistent as you can get for a WR. But I see your point. He's underrated though. If you put a healthy Sid Rice on the list than he has no chance, but imo he's in that 10-12 range.