Top 5 QB's so far

[AirGauge23]

11/08/10

1. Philip Rivers
2. Peyton Manning
3. Tom Brady
4. Drew Brees
5. Matt Ryan

[jazz873]

Eli > Ryan

[KeylessEntry]

look at the top 5 QB's by passer rating thus far

1. Michael Vick
2. Vince Young
3. Phillip Rivers
4. David Garrard
5. Peyton Manning


ridiculous

[Jailblazers7]

Originally Posted by KeylessEntry

look at the top 5 QB's by passer rating thus far

1. Michael Vick
2. Vince Young
3. Phillip Rivers
4. David Garrard
5. Peyton Manning


ridiculous

Black power up in this *****. Maybe Donovan and Troy Smith can turn it up so we can have a negro takeover.

[Scoooter]

Eli has to be up there.

[Snoop_Cat]

In no order:

Eli Manning
Philip Rivers
Peyton Manning

would appear to me be the undisputed top three. note that most of Eli's interceptions are not his fault as many of them are off deflections off his receivers.

I guess the next three are Rodgers, Brady, Brees out of default. But none of them have been particularly great this season.

[TDPrime2030]

11/26/10

1. Brady
2. Vick
3. Rivers
4. Ryan
5. Manning (Peyton)

[clipse026]

League leader in passing yards (for now), touchdowns and completion % with an 8-3 team doesn't make the top 5?

[Carbine]

Brees is certainly higher than Matt Ryan.

[Heilige]

1. Tom Brady
2. Michael Vick
3. Phillip Rivers
4. Drew Brees
5. Peyton Manning

[Stinky Dog]

LOL Matt Ryan and definitely not Drew Brees are not having better years than Aaron Rodgers.

[clipse026]

Originally Posted by Stinky Dog

LOL Matt Ryan and definitely not Drew Brees are not having better years than Aaron Rodgers.

Rodgers is 4 TDs and 700 yards (in 1 less game) back, 4 less completion %, similar QB rating, he's been sacked more times, and might possibly have the same record as Drew Brees after Sunday. I would say Drew is having a better or at least comparable year to Rodgers. Matt Ryan I won't argue about though.

[Rasheed1]

Tom Brady looked great yesterday

[Carbine]

If "top quarterbacks" just means who has been the best individually and not accounting for outside factors like the teams record and so on, how the hell is Tom Brady over Rivers?

If everything stays the same for both, this is what they end up with:

Tom Brady - 3900 yards/33touchdowns/6 interceptions

Phillip Rivers - 5100 yards/37 touchdowns/14 interceptions

Add to the fact that Rivers has been doing it with recievers we've never heard of, without his top guy in Vincent all year...and hasn't missed a beat when Gates hasn't been there..... even more impressive.

Rivers should be at the top of everyones list if this is just a "who's best" list.

[phelix2000]

Originally Posted by Carbine

If "top quarterbacks" just means who has been the best individually and not accounting for outside factors like the teams record and so on, how the hell is Tom Brady over Rivers?

If everything stays the same for both, this is what they end up with:

Tom Brady - 3900 yards/33touchdowns/6 interceptions

Phillip Rivers - 5100 yards/37 touchdowns/14 interceptions

Add to the fact that Rivers has been doing it with recievers we've never heard of, without his top guy in Vincent all year...and hasn't missed a beat when Gates hasn't been there..... even more impressive.

Rivers should be at the top of everyones list if this is just a "who's best" list.

Brady also lost Moss so don't like he has a whole bunch of great receivers. He has Welker, but Rivers has also had Gates for most of this season. Brady has also thrown half the amount of interceptions as Rivers. This is not to say Rivers is bad, but you can't act like Brady who is on top of most peoples list doesn't deserve it. Brady lost Moss and they completely restructured the passing game.