I hope Showtime starts a welterweight tournament like the jr. welter they have goin. They have a lot of WW fights in the next few months or so.
Devon Alex vs. Lee Purdy
Maidana vs. J. Lopez
Paulie vs. Broner
Andre Berto vs. Jesus Sota Karass
Keith Thurman vs. Diego Gabriel Chaves
Than you have Guerrero and Ortiz with out any opponents. And Amir Khan has been thinking of moving up. His last fight was at 143. They can do a lot of mix and matching here. Mayweather is probably picking someone from this group. Alexander looks like the most likely foe.
Robert Guerrero can get the winner of either Broner/Paulie and Maidana/Lopez. Ortiz can take the other Guerrero doesn't take.
Berto should fight Khan in a match up of most disappointing career so far.
Alexander was my prediction and everybody laughed at me!
If it has to be one of them, I hope he shows some dignity and takes on the winner of Maidana-Lopez. At least those guys have some guts...
And who the **** is Lee Purdy?? Taking on those tomato cans is just wrong
Huh? Alexander is far better than Maidana or Lopez.
I posted a few weeks ago that, of all the guys from that group (Khan, Bradley, Alexander, etc.), I thought Alexander offered the most interesting stylistic challenge for Mayweather.
That fight may not sell a ton of PPVs and it may bore people who don't appreciate pure boxers, but I think it is one of the best options out there, from a challenge standpoint. He has looked better to me at 147 than he did at 140, though it has only been 4(?) fights or so.
Alexander has become quite underrated. He won damn near every round against Maidana and that was a fight a lot of people pegged him to lose. Mayweather vs. Maidana would be a total farce.
you made some valid points. It's mostly because I like Maidana a lot and I can't stand this damn Alexander. He won against Maidana with throwing one punch and than holding. And he quit against Bradley like a bitch. Why wouldn't Floyd take Bradley??
and check out what you answered, when I wrote that Floyd might be picking Alexander:
Man I tried to follow your thoughts but when it comes to Mayweather, you're just a fanboy. First you said that Guerrero is the best fighter available - a guy who had no convincing win at 147 and never will do shit in boxing. Now you starting to defend Alexander?
I don't hate at Floyd. He's doing his exhibition fights and get money. I can't hate on a man getting dollars. But I have a problem with fans acting as he would pick the most dangerous opponents.
Floyd against Bradley would be OK. He's fighting JMM, though, and I think that's a great matchup.
And, I actually put a vote in for an Alexander fight long before anyone was talking about it...
It has nothing to do with "defending" Alexander. Of the guys who've come up from 140 relatively recently, he's one of the only guys I have an interest in as far as Mayweather is concerned. And, it is inarguable Guerrero was amongst the best fights Mayweather could have conceivably made this last time around. I don't quite remember saying it was the best fight, though. Please cite that reference.
Also, trust me, if Khan ends up being the choice, I'll openly dislike that selection right now as much as I did weeks ago when I made that post. I think that fight stinks.
"Fanboy" is such a stupid term, especially in boxing. I've always really enjoyed watching Mayweather fight, but he's hardly alone. I enjoy the fight game and the different styles and how they matchup. Boxing is the kind of sport wherein you don't have to constantly pick favorites and cheer one guy on above all others.
I look at it like a chess match and I'm always interested in seeing how guys stack up. I haven't seen Mayweather fight a young pure boxer like Alexander in a good while. Recently, it has been the Ortiz, Guerrero, Cotto variety. I think Devon brings something totally different to the table and I'd be interested. Whether or not this fight will sell to the masses or what his detractors think of it? I honestly couldn't care less.
Fact is, there is a devoted and large group of people who follow boxing and happen to despise Mayweather. I'm not one of them. There is a constant chant of "ducking" and "scared." I don't buy into any of that stuff for any fighter, really. That often puts me at odds with people partaking in boxing conversations on this forum. I'd say it has a lot more to do with people disliking Mayweather than me being a fan.
I call it how I see it and Alexander is a good fighter. Maidana was thoroughly dominated in that fight.
Last edited by RedBlackAttack : 05-16-2013 at 04:08 AM.
I'm not impressed with Alexander at all. He got a couple of gift decisions in the Kotelnik and Matthyse fights. Plus he quit against Bradley. He'd be no challenge for Floyd. There are no 140 or 147 fighters than can challenge Floyd. Everyone only has a puncher's chance against him and that's a very small chance. Alexander has looked better at 147 though. It's too bad Brook got injured again. This Purdy dude doesn't seem like he'll be a challenge at all.
Yes, 'fanboy' is a bad term but some people do worship fighters in a fanatic way.
You think that there is no ducking in boxing? wow.
But you're right about Maidana. That's just my personal taste. It's only because I would prefere to see Maidana getting this big pay day than Alexander.
My question about you not liking Mayweather had absolutely nothing to do with Alexander. It was obvious you were insinuating he was going to take the path of least resistance.
I wasn't sure where you stood on the range of people who dislike Mayweather, so I asked.
And, in the other post, I wasn't asked whether I'd rather see Khan or Alexander... Kizzle brought up Khan. I brought up Alexander as the guy from that group (Khan, Alexander, Bradley, etc) that I'd like to see.
I don't feel I should have to explain myself, tbh. I've been consistent in every comment I've made. Is Alexander the absolute most appealing challenger? No. That would be Canelo at this point.
But, if that fight doesn't happen, Alexander is a guy I wouldn't mind seeing. Much more than the likes of Khan, Maidana, etc.
And, I don't think I've ever heard "fanboy" used as anything but in a derogatory way.
If it is any consolation, I think choosing Alexander would tank for Showtime and they may start asking for some of their money back... Because that simply won't sell, regardless of what I think about it.
Guy who did the interview used to post here somewhat regularly.
Floyd Sr. talking rubbish and he needs to get that froth out the side of his mouth. It was making me a little queasy.
If Floyd's team is making this big a deal about the weight in actual negotiations, I think they're making a big mistake and I don't blame Alvarez for walking away. That is assuming he speaks for the whole team, but I said in an earlier post I don't put much credence in what trainers have to say... That is especially true when it comes to the Mayweather clan. They tend to be loose cannons.
No one could honestly believe Canelo has any chance at coming into that fight 150 pounds or less. Hell, 160 pounds would be a stretch for him. I think I read he was 166 against Trout.
I also think Floyd Sr. is underestimating the way putting on a massive amount of weight in a couple of days can be detrimental to a fighter. It doesn't always work out in their favor.
Btw, good work by a former(?) ISH poster. He pushed Sr. without making it too obvious. Glad to see he's still doing his thing.
Last edited by RedBlackAttack : 05-16-2013 at 04:48 AM.