Originally Posted by Kevin_Gamble
Melo isn't as good at basketball though. So I will go with Carter.
Better as a scorer and rebounder. More clutch. Not as good defensively but Carter isn't an All-NBA defensive player with massive impact on that side of the ball. Carter's better at running the offense, but it isn't like Melo's really been put in that position that much.
Carter was more athletic and exciting.
Just my two sense I guess.