He's a top tier QB but i'd have to disagree. Regular season does matter. He's top five though. The fact you'd probably rather have him over better QB's in the postseason is something to be proud of though.
I disagree. no one holds that title. the best QBs from the last few seasons hasnt been that great. Brees/Rodgers/Brady. However, Eli is playing better than them now. You could even argue Flacco or Ryan being better than Eli. Its really a tossup. Cant decide the best QB title until December imho.
I made a thread "Eli is the most underrated QB in the NFL" this time last year and got LAMBASTED by everyone. Be great to dig that one up.
Doesn't look like you got "LAMBASTED by everyone". More like it turned into a typical p.tiddy "Why don't you love Romo more???" exercise in futility.
And yes, he has an argument vs any QB in the game right now. Some will have a bigger arm or more athleticism or some other reason to prefer them. But none have delivered in the clutch the way he has over the last few years.