Eli Manning and the Dreaded Underrated Word

[GOBB]

Neither has Tony Romo.

[Sarcastic]

Originally Posted by PowerGlove

Seriously??

I understand taking him over Bradford and Stafford, maybe even romo but there is no way someone in their right mind is taking him over Ryan,Vick,Romo and he isnt in the same class as a Rivers or Roethlisberger.

What has Rivers or Ryan done that Manning hasn't?

[Real Men Wear Green]

Originally Posted by Sarcastic

What has Rivers or Ryan done that Manning hasn't?

Great stats. Eli has never had a 34TD/11 INT-level year and has never gone for 4700 yards.

[Playmakers Dad]

Originally Posted by Real Men Wear Green

Great stats. Eli has never had a 34TD/11 INT-level year and has never gone for 4700 yards.

And when has Matt Ryan thrown for 34 TDs? or anywhere near 4700 yards? ROFL.

Eli's thrown for more yards, more TDs in a season then Matt Ryan.

This thread is evidence as to why he's underrated, because posters think Matt Ryan is a better QB.

[niko]

Originally Posted by PowerGlove

Seriously??

I understand taking him over Bradford and Stafford, maybe even romo but there is no way someone in their right mind is taking him over Ryan,Vick,Romo and he isnt in the same class as a Rivers or Roethlisberger.

Why wouldn't we take him over Vick and Romo? Are you watching this season? I want no part of Vick. Every problem he cured last year (holding the ball too long, throwing into traffic, havnig happy feet) is back 100%. And romo makes mistakes just like Eli, just at worse times.

[Real Men Wear Green]

Originally Posted by Playmakers Dad

And when has Matt Ryan thrown for 34 TDs? or anywhere near 4700 yards? ROFL.

Eli's thrown for more yards, more TDs in a season then Matt Ryan.

This thread is evidence as to why he's underrated, because posters think Matt Ryan is a better QB.

Rivers was who I was talking about. Please reevaluate within that context.

[Real Men Wear Green]

Originally Posted by niko

Why wouldn't we take him over Vick and Romo? Are you watching this season? I want no part of Vick. Every problem he cured last year (holding the ball too long, throwing into traffic, havnig happy feet) is back 100%. And romo makes mistakes just like Eli, just at worse times.

Both have higher ceilings, but I agree Manning has been more consistent this season.

[PowerGlove]

Originally Posted by Carbine

Matt Ryan hasn't done anything to warrant being above Manning.

I guess we arent including last year in anything lmfao. Mr. Ryan threw 28 tds and only 9 ints last year.

[PowerGlove]

Originally Posted by niko

Why wouldn't we take him over Vick and Romo? Are you watching this season? I want no part of Vick. Every problem he cured last year (holding the ball too long, throwing into traffic, havnig happy feet) is back 100%. And romo makes mistakes just like Eli, just at worse times.

What else is Vick supposed to? His protection hasnt been great. When Eli goes on his midseason collapse again, we'll see what everyone says then.

[niko]

Originally Posted by PowerGlove

What else is Vick supposed to? His protection hasnt been great. When Eli goes on his midseason collapse again, we'll see what everyone says then.

Yes, so unlike Vick who piles on the titles, right? When Vick gets knocked out and misses 5 games give me a call.

[PowerGlove]

Originally Posted by niko

Yes, so unlike Vick who piles on the titles, right? When Vick gets knocked out and misses 5 games give me a call.

*sigh*

titles? what has he even done in the playoffs since then that lucky ass throw?

anyways, like i said. when he goes into that horrific stretch of play which seems to be an annual thing. everyone will take vick over him again.

[Playmakers Dad]

Originally Posted by PowerGlove

I guess we arent including last year in anything lmfao. Mr. Ryan threw 28 tds and only 9 ints last year.

so please explain how that makes him a better QB then Eli?

Eli threw for for more yards, more TDs last year. His interception total is grossly inflated as well.

[PowerGlove]

Originally Posted by Playmakers Dad

so please explain how that makes him a better QB then Eli?

Eli threw for for more yards, more TDs last year. His interception total is grossly inflated as well.

This is where you tell me that his interceptions were a tipped ball and freak occurrences lol

[leopoldstotch]

i don't know what to say about eli. his 1st 3 years were subpar. at times he was good, and other times he was just plain horrible. his last 4 years are underrated. we have to remember he's posting some solid numbers with some not so elite wide receivers. the last 2 years he's been fortunate enough to have hakeem nicks around.

[Playmakers Dad]

Originally Posted by PowerGlove

This is where you tell me that his interceptions were a tipped ball and freak occurrences lol

Idont have to tell you anything just waiting for you to explain how matt ryan throwing 29 tds and 9 ints make him a better qb?