What do you think of Tony Romo? Top 10? Top 5? Your thoughts...

[niko]

Let's take the Eli/Romo argument from the other side. Without using Eli as a crutch (it's a way to overrate Romo indirectly, to compare him to a multi Super Bowl winner) what level is Romo? Top 10? Top 5? (Stretch). Is he getting better? Potential Super Bowl Winner?

Let's take a deep look at Romo. As to not bias the discussion, ill post my thoughts later (you don't know my thoughts, trust me).

P.Tiddy, start us off...

[GOBB]

Top 5? No way. Not even close. within that 8-12 range I say. I want to say top 10.

[-p.tiddy-]

top-10 for sure...and perhaps an argument could be made for 4 or 5

he is doing great this year though, numbers a little lower than usual but that has a lot to do with going to Seattle, just ask Rodgers

[-p.tiddy-]

He was really amazing week 1 in NY for sure...I'm sure just about everyone in here witnessed that

[UtahJazzFan88]

He's about 8 or 9...

Brady
Rodgers
Brees
Eli
Big Ben
Ryan
Stafford
Peyton (I would put him here right now, still too unknown after injury, could fall or get higher on this list).

I'd put him in the same class as Rivers, Flacco, Cutler, Vick.

[-p.tiddy-]

Originally Posted by UtahJazzFan88

I'd put him in the same class as Rivers, Flacco, Cutler, Vick.

He is currently much better than ALL of those QBs except maybe Flacco who has looked great this year

He is better than Stafford as well...Stafford is in that group

Romo and Flacco are above that group

[GOBB]

Originally Posted by -p.tiddy-

top-10 for sure...and perhaps an argument could be made for 4 or 5

he is doing great this year though, numbers a little lower than usual but that has a lot to do with going to Seattle, just ask Rodgers

No argument can be made for 4 or 5. Period.

[sunsfan1357]

I think there's a certain point where QBs just start to become interchangeable in any rankings. Once you get past what is generally regarded as the elite of Rodgers, Brees, Brady then arguments can be made for a few people to be in 4-8 range. I'd probably put Romo in the 6-8 range personally.

[-p.tiddy-]

Vick has a 66.0 rating and is on the verge of being benched...

not sure what River's problem is, I think he just lost whatever he had somehow...

Stafford gets lots of yardage from deep prayers to Calvin but is having a bad start...


none of those guys should be placed above Romo right now...

[niko]

Originally Posted by -p.tiddy-

He was really amazing week 1 in NY for sure...I'm sure just about everyone in here witnessed that

Absolutely, although context - we were (literally) playing CB 4 and 5. Not 2 and 3. 4 and 5.

[Sarcastic]

He's somewhere in 6-10 range.

Top 5 are Brady, Brees, Rogers, Eli, Roethlisberger.

6-10 are Romo, Ryan, Peyton(should be in top 5 but we don't know with the injury), Rivers, Stafford.

[GOBB]

Originally Posted by -p.tiddy-

Vick has a 66.0 rating and is on the verge of being benched...

not sure what River's problem is, I think he just lost whatever he had somehow...

Stafford gets lots of yardage from deep prayers to Calvin but is having a bad start...


none of those guys should be placed above Romo right now...

Vick is not on the verge of being bench. Please stop talkin out your ass.

And enough of this Stafford crap. If Sam Bradford was throwing to Calvin Johnson you do NOT make the same argument. You sound dumb which isnt unusual of course. Now its a crime to play with arguably the best WR in the NFL? Hilarious. On one hand you argue how Sam has no help and if he did he be better. On another you're bashing a QB who has amazing help in CJ and knocking him.

[-p.tiddy-]

Andy Reid suggests Michael Vick could get benched

lol

my asshole > GoBB

[-p.tiddy-]

I think Sam Bradford is better than Stafford, and has been this year WITHOUT Calvin even

Bradford is underrated, Stafford overrated

[-p.tiddy-]

Originally Posted by Sarcastic

He's somewhere in 6-10 range.

Top 5 are Brady, Brees, Rogers, Eli, Roethlisberger.

6-10 are Romo, Ryan, Peyton(should be in top 5 but we don't know with the injury), Rivers, Stafford.

naw...not those 2

maybe not Peyton either...but hard to tell