Brandon Marshall is a Top 2 WR this year

[Tarik One]

Call me a homer, but at this very moment, if I had to select 2 wideouts, Brandon will be one of them. He may not have the track record that measures up to other household names (Johnson, Johnson, Fitzgerald, etc), but I'd certainly take him for a big game or a playoff run. I don't care about stats. Dude has been clutch this year.

[TheSilentKiller]

I still take Calvin as my definitive number one. Marshall made an excellent case for himself this year to be placed in the top tier conversation (with Calvin, Fitz, Andre). I honestly might agree with you. He is playing incredibly well with a not so perfect qb.

[Carbine]

Don't let the guy who doesn't think he's a top 10 wideout see this thread, he will freak.

[-p.tiddy-]

He is top 5, I stated that in here before the year even started...he is just so big and over powering, most CBs are no match for him.

[TheNaturalWR]

Originally Posted by Carbine

Don't let the guy who doesn't think he's a top 10 wideout see this thread, he will freak.

Not really....It doesn't bother me at all. I'd openly admit that he's proven me wrong but me thinking he wasn't a top 10 receiver before/the first 3 weeks of the season was perfectly reasonable. He's in my top 5 but he's a distant 5th, still drops too many sure-fire TDs.
1. Calvin Johnson
2. Andre Johnson/AJ Green
3. Andre Johnson/AJ Green
4. Larry Fitzgerald


5. Brandon Marshall

[-p.tiddy-]

And I will take this moment to say that Dez should be in everyone's top-10 now

[jazz873]

This is before the Packers game. Pretty crazy


Cutler- 213 completions for 2,495 yards and 16 touchdowns
Marshall- 101 receptions for 1,342 yards and 9 touchdowns (we'll say 8 since 1 was from Campbell vs SF)

Completions- 47% to Marshall
Yards- 54% is Marshall
Touchdowns- 50% is Marshall

[bisk]

Calvin Johnson
Brandon Marshall
AJ Green
Andre Johnson

Vincent Jackson
Wes Welker
Reggie Wayne
Demaryius Thomas

Roddy White
Dez Bryant
Marques Colston

[bisk]

That's in terms of this year's production, that's why Fitz isn't in there.

[Real Men Wear Green]

I wanted to see the Pats make a deal for Fitz so badly last year. Get him a good QB and he's in the convo. Put him with a guy like Brady or Rogers and he'll challenge for records.

[Jackass18]

Inb4 pt says Dez Bryant

[miggyme1]

Originally Posted by Jackass18

Inb4 pt says Dez Bryant

in after u thought ya dumba.s.s opinion mattered!

[Jackass18]

Originally Posted by -p.tiddy-

And I will take this moment to say that Dez should be in everyone's top-10 now

Nevermind, too late

[Nanners]

if i am picking the top two wrs, one is calvin and the other is aj green or julio

brandon marshall might be top 5 but he is not top 2 in my book.


edit: lol at nobody in this thread even mentioning julio. if julio was getting the same number of targets that brandon marshall gets...game over

you guys can hate on primetime all you want, i guess i am a "homer" too because I would rate dez pretty much neck and neck with brandon marshall.

[-p.tiddy-]

yep Julio is top-10 for sure...over White, even if White has more production this year, Julio is the bigger freak

I think he is top-5 even


Andre has finished the year strong as hell and is top-10 but he isn't the same though still, he can't get off a press the same.

Fitz is hard to rank now because of no QB, but the fact that Roberts has better numbers than him is strange, he is still top-10 but I am thinking he might have dropped from the top teir

I think my top-10 would be

1. Calvin
2. AJ
3. Marshall
4. Julio
5. Fitz
6. Andre
7. Vincent
8. Wayne
9. Dez
10. Demaryius