All-Star reserves, snubs, etc. (merged topics)

[poorlilrich]

Who is going to make it? Who should make it but probably wont? and who is going to make it but doesn't deserve to? Who will be the biggest snub?

My allstar reserves
EAST:
Butler
Oneal
Carter
Howard
Kidd
Curry
Rip

WEST:
Melo
Nash
Dirk
R allen
B davis
Marion
Deron

Snubs: Z randolph, Amare, J howard, Brand...

[Howard5Dirk41]

7 people not 5

8 for west since Yao is out.

[GoRapz]

do positions matter for reserves? if not I think Amare should be in there somewhere.

[poorlilrich]

Originally Posted by Howard5Dirk41

7 people not 5

8 for west since Yao is out.

fixed it

[raiderfan19]

Originally Posted by poorlilrich

Who is going to make it? Who should make it but probably wont? and who is going to make it but doesn't deserve to? Who will be the biggest snub?

My allstar reserves
EAST:
Butler
Oneal
Carter
Howard
Kidd
Curry
Rip

WEST:
Melo
Nash
Dirk
R allen
B davis
Marion
Deron

Snubs: Z randolph, Amare, J howard, Brand...

there is a 0 percent chance that your western team is correct...

[Howard5Dirk41]

Originally Posted by poorlilrich

Who is going to make it? Who should make it but probably wont? and who is going to make it but doesn't deserve to? Who will be the biggest snub?

My allstar reserves
EAST:
Butler
Oneal
Carter
Howard
Kidd
Curry
Rip

WEST:
Melo
Nash
Dirk
R allen
B davis
Marion
Deron

Snubs: Z randolph, Amare, J howard, Brand...

Boozer was surely voted in because votes were due 1 day before news broke on his injury.

Baron Davis has no chance of making it

Deron Williams would have been Boozer

Add Josh Howard and Amare instead.

Originally Posted by Howard5Dirk41

Boozer was surely voted in because votes were due 1 day before news broke on his injury.

Baron Davis has no chance of making it

Deron Williams would have been Boozer

Add Josh Howard and Amare instead.

obviously a mavs fan

[Howard5Dirk41]

Originally Posted by P-Forty21

obviously a mavs fan

Have you watched national broadcasts for the past month? everyone is saying Josh Howard deserves to be there, so I guess they're all Mav homers like me as well huh?

Originally Posted by P-Forty21

obviously a mavs fan

IF DWIGHT IS NOT IN THE EAST, IM GONNA RATTLE A CAGE !!!

but im pretty sure he's in

[The Drifter]

I want Carter to make it, I've always been a big carter fan and I do think he deserves it. Redd has some good stats but I see Carters game as better .....

Amare' probably won't make it this year because of the amount of good Centers and Power Forwards this year.

Baron Davis probably won't either, I mean theres Nash, Deron, Allen, Iverson , that to me takes him out automatically.

I don't think Howard should make it over Carmelo, I know Howard is on a great team but Melo is having a Superstar year.

Anyone remember when Cassell made the team a couple of years ago on the wolves ? He was getting I think 19.5 and 8 assist and shooting 49 from the field, Damn I thought those were some good stats ...Thank god for Deron and Nash bringing back some good stats.

[Timmeh]

Not as a Bobcats fan, but Okafor needs to be in for the east. He's been consistent all year long and he deserves to be in the game.

[despurs]

Tony parker should also be considered.

[boozehound]

utah should have a rep. Okur is my vote.

[boozehound]

Originally Posted by GoRapz

do positions matter for reserves? if not I think Amare should be in there somewhere.

yes to a degree. The coaches are told they should pick 2 g, 2f and 1 c with 2 open spots. But if they think a player can play the 2 even if he generally plays the 3 for his team they could vote them in as a guard.

[CakeorDeath]

Tony parker should also be considered

Not ahead of Deron Williams, especially considering that it would be the Spurs' second player and the Jazz would be left with 0.