JR Smith vs Jamal Crawford for 6th Man of The Year

[jimmy77x]

Jr Smith- 16/5/2 vs Crawford 16/2/1

Imo Jr is just an all around better player than Crawford, they are about even stat wise except JR averages more rebounds, so who will emerge to be 6th man of the year?

[Chapallaz]

Jamal is just as good if not better all round than JR. Much better playmaker for a start.

[Fudge]

Thread should be JR Smith vs Jamal Crawford vs Kevin Martin.

Give it to whoever has the best team record at the end of the year.

[ClutchOver9000]

Originally Posted by Chapallaz

Jamal is just as good if not better all round than JR. Much better playmaker for a start.

No, JR is the more well-rounded player. Better defender, better rebounder.

[Chapallaz]

Originally Posted by ClutchOver9000

No, JR is the more well-rounded player. Better defender, better rebounder.

LOL. Yup that automatically makes him better all round.

[Levity]

he may not be scoring as much, but jarret jack should be in the conversation as well.

[ClutchOver9000]

Originally Posted by Chapallaz

LOL. Yup that automatically makes him better all round.

Both capable of lighting it up, Jamal the better playmaker (JR's playmaking is underrated though), JR the better defender and rebounder.

[Chapallaz]

Originally Posted by ClutchOver9000

Both capable of lighting it up, Jamal the better playmaker (JR's playmaking is underrated though), JR the better defender and rebounder.

Clutch! 2-2. Seems like thats how you look at this.

[Whoah10115]

Smith is also playing a lot more minutes than Crawford is. If you watch the Clippers you'll see the way their offense moves and within that offense I think Crawford has been more impressive. But this is one hell of a top 3.


Jack and Landry have also been great, as has Javale McGee. Ray Allen also deserves a little mention. But the top 3 is way ahead.

[Chapallaz]

Originally Posted by Whoah10115

Smith is also playing a lot more minutes than Crawford is. If you watch the Clippers you'll see the way their offense moves and within that offense I think Crawford has been more impressive. But this is one hell of a top 3.


Jack and Landry have also been great, as has Javale McGee. Ray Allen also deserves a little mention. But the top 3 is way ahead.

McGee has been awful for an underachieving team. He makes so many dumb mistakes and misses assignment upon assignment. Drummond has actually been better, much better as a big man off the bench. Heck even Greg smith has had a better impact as a first big off the bench. Mahinmi has been better as well. Ginobili is better than any option mentioned btw.

[no pun intended]

Crawford hasn't been playing defense as well as Smith this year.

[Whoah10115]

Originally Posted by Chapallaz

McGee has been awful for an underachieving team. He makes so many dumb mistakes and misses assignment upon assignment. Drummond has actually been better, much better as a big man off the bench. Heck even Greg smith has had a better impact as a first big off the bench. Mahinmi has been better as well. Ginobili is better than any option mentioned btw.

McGee has been awful? I didn't see that coming.

[Chapallaz]

Originally Posted by Whoah10115

McGee has been awful? I didn't see that coming.

Sarcasm?

[Cali Syndicate]

Jarret jack or Carl landry gets my vote

[iDunk]

JR > Jamal by a little bit