Originally Posted by raiderfan19
Jeff bag well
We're all as good as miggy at their peaks and that's just off the top of my head
Brian Giles best season - 174 wRC+ and .444 wOBA
Thome - 189 wRC+ and .461 wOBA
Bagwell - 205 wRC+ and .488 wOBA
Berkman - 164 wRC+ and .440 wOBA
ARod - 174 wRC+ and .436 wOBA
Manny - 185 wRC+ and .459 wOBA
Miggy - 205 wRC+ and .470 wOBA
So obviously Giles isn't anywhere near Miggy. Berkman isn't either.....or ARod.
Manny is clearly behind, same with Thome.
The only one that's debatable is Bagwell, but he only did it for 110 games that year and never whiffed that type of production again.
Here's the real list as to who has been as good or better than peak Miggy from recent memory on offense only:
Jeff Bagwell (if you want to count his 110 game season)
Pujols isn't even in the discussion really. His best year was 184 wRC+ and .464 wOBA
Bottom line - Miggy is having a legit historic year on offense that we haven't seen is a very long time.