does anyone not have Brady as their top 2 QB all time?

[CelticBaller]

Not saying I'm not, but Marino definitely has nothing over Brady, nothing.

[Euroleague]

Originally Posted by mlh1981

I don't recall Marino's dolphins ever having a good running attack or defense.

Brady had outstanding early career team success, but was part of a top notch organization, one certainly more well rounded than Marino's Dolphins. Since his last Super Bowl win, he has lost the same number of Super Bowls as Peyton Manning, and has come up short numerous times in AFC Championship games. Him and Manning have very similar resumes since 2005.

I still said Brady was top 5, so it's not like I'm dissing the guy.

So let me get this straight.............EXCLUDING Brady's 3 Superbowls, he's pretty much EQUAL to Manning, and you are saying this is somehow a negative against Brady's resume.......................

[mlh1981]

Originally Posted by Euroleague

So let me get this straight.............EXCLUDING Brady's 3 Superbowls, he's pretty much EQUAL to Manning, and you are saying this is somehow a negative against Brady's resume.......................

His 3 Super Bowls are an outstanding accomplishment and I would put him in the top 5, but he's not in the top 2 QB's of all time. That's kinda where I'm getting at with this. Neither is Manning.

[Carbine]

I think it's incredibly hard not to have Peyton Manning or Tom Brady in the top 5 of all time.

I don't think theirs an argument to be made to support it. Not the way we judge players.

[Al Thorton]

Originally Posted by -p.tiddy-

I have

1. Montana
2. Peyton

why? they both have a better resume than Brady does IMO


I have Brady at 3 though so...just one spot off

I got this and then 3-way tie at 3rd with Marino, Elway, and Brady

[kobebeangoat]

Brady is GOAT.

[RoundMoundOfReb]

Originally Posted by kobebeangoat

Brady is GOAT.

Judging by your name - Your opinion about who the GOAT is is not really valuable.

[KingBeasley08]

Originally Posted by RoundMoundOfReb

Judging by your name - Your opinion about who the GOAT is is not really valuable.

[Bless Mathews]

Originally Posted by -p.tiddy-

I have

1. Montana
2. Peyton

why? they both have a better resume than Brady does IMO


I have Brady at 3 though so...just one spot off

Lololol.

How does Peyton have better resume than brady?

Lolololll.
L

[Carbine]

Manning:

7 all-pro first teams
3 all-pro first teams
5 MVP awards
1 superbowl mvp
1 Superbowl

Brady:

2 all-pro first team
1 all-pro second team
2 mvp awards
2 superbowl mvps
3 Superbowls

[-p.tiddy-]

Originally Posted by Carbine

Manning:

7 all-pro first teams
3 all-pro first teams
5 MVP awards
1 superbowl mvp
1 Superbowl

Brady:

2 all-pro first team
1 all-pro second team
2 mvp awards
2 superbowl mvps
3 Superbowls

right...you can look at all-time career numbers as well

all-time passing yardage
all-time passing TDs
all-time passer rating
etc
etc

Manning wins


the one place where Brady might defeat Manning though is SB performance

and Montana has them both crushed in playoff performance...in a more difficult era of passing even

[Bless Mathews]

Originally Posted by -p.tiddy-

right...you can look at all-time career numbers as well

all-time passing yardage
all-time passing TDs
all-time passer rating
etc
etc

Manning wins


the one place where Brady might defeat Manning though is SB performance

and Montana has them both crushed in playoff performance...in a more difficult era of passing even

Lolololololol


Who cares???

.3333 winning percentage in Super Bowl.

Everything else doesn't mean shit when considering goat status

No Qb can be considered goat failing that miserably on the biggest and most important stage.

Smh.

[Carbine]

It's settled, let's rank GOAT QB's by winning percentage in super bowls!

New top 5 of all time:

1. Montana
2. Bradshaw
3. Aikman
4. Star
5. Eli

[kobebeangoat]

Manning better all time than Brady

[CelticBaller]

Originally Posted by Carbine

It's settled, let's rank GOAT QB's by winning percentage in super bowls!

New top 5 of all time:

1. Montana
2. Bradshaw
3. Aikman
4. Star
5. Eli

sb winning % should be included into the criteria, not create a whole different ranking