Who should shed the status of "Star" or Budding Star"...

[hateraid]

....based on their consistancy of being injured. Someone we should give up the term potential or franchise player and just stick to the reputation of being a solid to normal contributor.

hateraid picks:

Quentin Richardson, Darius Miles

[_KP_The_Familia_]

Originally Posted by hateraid

....based on their consistancy of being injured. Someone we should give up the term potential or franchise player and just stick to the reputation of being a solid to normal contributor.

hateraid picks:

Quentin Richardson, Darius Miles

I think people stopped thinking either of these dudes would be stars, years ago

[hateraid]

Originally Posted by _KP_The_Familia_

I think people stopped thinking either of these dudes would be stars, years ago

All right, to shake things up I'll say Jermaine O'Neal

lamar odom

[TMacsOneGoodEye]

Ron Artest.

[different107]

Ricky Davis

[Da KO King]

The only correct answer to this question is Shaun Livingston.

[Ianou]

Originally Posted by Da KO King

The only correct answer to this question is Shaun Livingston.

He won't be playing for at least another year.

[Señor Cedric]

Marvin Williams
Sebastian Telfair
Adam Morrison
Devin Harris
Mike Dunleavy Jr........... muhaha
Kwame Brown (was he ever considered one?)
Stromile Swift
Jameer Nelson
Martell Webster
Chris Wilcox
Andrei Kirilenko

Looks fair to me.

[RidonKs]

I think AK, and possibly Wilcox and Morrison, are the only ones from that list who would ever get a "budding star" label. I think that label refers more to a Brandon Roy type, who has already come into their own with solid stats. Not saying it's undeserving for Ray, he's just an example of a player who I think would get that status.

[qwerty]

Originally Posted by hateraid

All right, to shake things up I'll say Jermaine O'Neal

20 and 10 isnt good enough?

[hateraid]

Originally Posted by qwerty

20 and 10 isnt good enough?

Often injured, can't be relied on for a whole season. That was the point of the thread.