Would You Ever Trade Marvin Williams or Josh Smith?

[marny_navis]

Originally Posted by kurupt

i dont want him though, anyways your gm sucks ass so haaaa

lol. I don't like Bargnani just because he's not too strong and isn't much of a rebounder. I think the Hawks need a point guard and a banger inside next to Al Horford, and Bargnani doesn't fit the bill. Yeah, Hawks Management is a sorry thing, so they probably would try to do something like this and say, "Atlanta, we fixed the PG and PF positions. Bow down to us. Just wait until you've seen how Bargnani can't rebound and how Al needs another guy down low. Then you can bash us and we'll just keep sittin' back, drinking our coffee watching the team suck."

[kurupt]

i havent watched many atl games but isnt horford a good inside presence on both ends? or does he get his offense form mid range? cuz if hes a potential dominant low post scorer bargnani would be a good fit next to him, bargnani is all right just not numbr 1 pick material and defintely not a fit on our team,

but honestly a calderon for williams swap just makes so much sense

btw I HATE BARGANANI WITH A PASSION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[marny_navis]

I don't watch the Hawks much, either, but I still think Horford should have another banger next to him down low.

Williams/Calderon wouldn't be too bad, IMO, if the Hawks got a future pick or a nice filler.

[kurupt]

joey grahm is the filler

[marny_navis]

I'd take that.

1- Calderon
2- Johnson
3- Smith
4- Horford
5- ?

We'll need to go get a center.

[kurupt]

Originally Posted by marny_navis

I'd take that.

1- Calderon
2- Johnson
3- Smith
4- Horford
5- ?

We'll need to go get a center.

zaza? i think this would be a good deal too, calderon bargnanni, grahm for zaza, childress marvin , and law

[marny_navis]

Originally Posted by kurupt

zaza? i think this would be a good deal too, calderon bargnanni, grahm for zaza, childress marvin , and law

Hmmmm... Well, no one gets raped too badly in that deal.

[Qwyjibo]

I'm a Raptors fan and I'd definitely be for a Marvin for Calderon trade.

The problem is that it might turn out to be a PR nightmare whether Calderon does well or not. Marvin Williams was the #2 pick and was taken ahead of Chris Paul and Deron Williams (and even Felton can fall into here too). Trading Williams now for a PG that is clearly inferior to those big 2 and, IMO Felton also, would not go over well with people. The management would basically be saying "yep, we REALLY screwed that draft pick up and now we'll settle for something less". I think this is one reason such a deal may never happen.

[kurupt]

exactly which is why it wont happen but should, and bc wont give up on bargnani yet,