knicks fans would u trade carmelo anthony for lebron james?

[knickscity]

Are people out there on this board insane or what?



You've already established something like this, after a mere chunk of games? Not an entire season, nor after a training camp together....no......a small chunk of games, and its ALL OVER, TRADE CARMELO, HE RUINED THE TEAM!




Christ, this board is collectively not very bright, nor are they patient.

They aren't Knicks fans, only fans of certain players.

Only a fool would want a player on their team that said NO, I don't want you.

[griffmoney1784]

all of you who say its melos fault are god damn IIIIIIIdiots


the knicks suck because

A) they gutted their team for 1 guy and a hasbeen

B) their coach doesnt teach defense

melo is just fine. nothing wrong with him.

i personaly think lebron has more to offer a team. but he offers too much of whatever it is to get his numbers. too much lebron = stagnant offense

/thread

[Zackmorris]

i would and im a knicks fans too
carmelo just ruined the team

Real talk, you're an idiot.

[HorryIsMyMVP]

No he wouldn't.

He is making that very clear.

He might not fit in with the team but certainly his attitude is on par with the majority of the fan base. The world revolves around the under acheiving Lebron just like the fan's world revolves around the under acheiving Knicks. We haven't won anything in 37 years but yet we think we are god's gift to the NBA.

[Clutch]

i would and im a knicks fans too
carmelo just ruined the team

And yet he is the only reason why the Magic didn't blow us out of the building last night.
He was the best player on the court (OK,Dwight,but our weak centers were guarding him so that was a pick-up game for him).
He was efficient and he was setting easy looks for the teammates,much better than Billups/Douglas do.

[iDunk]

No, Melo's grown on me.

[knicksman]

no ..most great perimeter players have jumpshots so the chance of winning a championship is the same with the 2

[LastChanceToWin]

Melo has made it out of the first round of the playoffs just once. This guy is not even close to valuable. I would trade him for almost any perennial all-star in the NBA, as long as that player is not old.

[Lebron23]

no ..most great perimeter players have jumpshots so the chance of winning a championship is the same with the 2

http://www.insidehoops.com/forum/sho...d.php?t=214720

Watch some Heats Games. You guys needs to be updated. Melo is not even consistent enough to lead his team deeper into the playoffs. He only advanced in the 2nd round when the Nuggets acquired Billups.

[knicksman]

http://www.insidehoops.com/forum/sho...d.php?t=214720

Watch some Heats Games. You guys needs to be updated. Melo is not even consistent enough to lead his team deeper into the playoffs. He only advanced in the 2nd round when the Nuggets acquired Billups.

im sure lebron would be a first round exit too or would have not made it to the playoffs if his on the west

[bagelred]

If I'm the Knicks, I would look for a package of good young players to build around for Melo.

Something like a Gallinari, Chandler, Felton, Mozgov for Melo and Billups. Just off the top of my head.

[PurpleChuck]

Knicks fans in denial!

Face it, you would get down on your knees for Lebron James.

[Lebron23]

im sure lebron would be a first round exit too or would have not made it to the playoffs if his on the west

LeBron is a better playoffs performers than Crymelo Anthony. Thank God LeBron didn't sign with the Knicks.

[knicksman]

LeBron is a better playoffs performers than Crymelo Anthony. Thank God LeBron didn't sign with the Knicks.

what playoff..losing to orlando and boston as a topdog

lebron vs melo
11-4

fact: bird jordan, and kobe are all great shooters..lebrick is not

[Hoopz2332]

no ..most great perimeter players have jumpshots so the chance of winning a championship is the same with the 2