what exactly has vick proven? why is everyone suggesting he move up.
oh yeah, he won at lambeau. eli's only done it twice
I hate posts like this. First, what have the Qbs listed in the next year proven more than Vick has? Second, what does Eli have to do with Vick and why he should be moved up a tier? Oh I'll answer this one for you since you'll spend f*cking eternity trying to answer my first question. Eli has nothing to do with the question. Get off dudes nuts.
dude was a dog killer. he can't even stay on the field an entire year. he has a lot more to prove than the other guys in the tier above him. plus he is making alpha qb bucks and what does he do? get hurt and play barely above .500 on one of the most talented teams in the league. dream team.
so to answer your question, the QBs in a tier above him have proven to stay on the field. and to answer your 2nd question, eli has little to do with him besides the fact eli has so much less hype and has proven so much damn more than him. get off the dog killers nuts.
I'd take him over most the guys in the tier above him
I think that's why putting him where Dilfer put him makes sense. He followed up his rookie year with a dud (yes we know he was crippled all year, WR's suck, etc.), but despite the excuses he's had one good year and one bad year. Why wouldn't his status be classified as potentially going either way?
Because he has the hardware and big game clutchness that the others below him do not. Right or wrong that's why. I personally think he belongs in that group, but clearly below the first four.
He is going to be a hall of famer.
One thing I have to say is - Cam probably needs to be in that ring away category. If he were to go out and do what he has been doing, and win a ring, he'd jump up tremendously in rankings like Rodgers did after he exploded.
Because he has the hardware and big game clutchness that the others below him do not. Right or wrong that's why. I personally think he belongs in that group, but clearly below the first four.
He is going to be a hall of famer.
One thing I have to say is - Cam probably needs to be in that ring away category. If he were to go out and do what he has been doing, and win a ring, he'd jump up tremendously in rankings like Rodgers did after he exploded.
He will be in the HOF, but his regular season play is not on the level of Peyton, Brady, Brees, and Rogers.
Trent Dilfer's rankings of the QB's
