knick, that list is based on the QB's entire career not just how they preform in the one Super Bowl they won...
Romo has much better career numbers than Eli does, so no he wouldn't be on that list if he won a ring...
http://www.pro-football-reference.co...ing_career.htm
^^^ top 5 passer rating all time...no that doesn't mean Romo is better than Montana so don't even go there, different eras...but it does mean he has been great in the regular season...better than Eli