nobody is saying he's not a great player, but is he the best player in the NBA? no he's not. he's not the number 2 player either, or the number 3 player, or the number 4 player. he's definitely down a few places. that's why he is overrated.
he is the least dangerous MVP of all time i reckon. in the fourth quarter he has almost zero ability to win games. maybe that's not quite accurate, maybe he has the ability but not the desire, but whatever it is, he either can't or won't win close games. period. there's absolutely, ABSOLUTELY no room for argument here. none. zip. zilch. after ten seasons i don't know how garnett fans can even argue this with a straight face. the guy is a clear cut number 2 option when the game is on the line.