Originally Posted by -p.tiddy-
also, Fred Taylor is one of the most underrated RBs ever...only 1 PB yet his numbers are that of a top-20 all time...
and Gale Sayers is the most overrated, could someone tell me why this guy is found on so many top-10 lists?...his resume isn't anything even close to deserving of that.
He's high based on his impact in the era he played in. You keep harping on how long he played his total career stats when top lists arent always based on just that. Another reason why Earl Campbell is on top 10 lists. The period in which he played he dominated. Just because a guy compiles more stats than the other doesnt mean he was the better player.